Sheet Music v. Sound Waves: When Old Copyright Law Meets Modern MusicThe Ed Sheeran copyright dispute raises important questions about judicial deference and copyright scope under the 1909 Act.
The Briefing: NBA Teams Fight Back Against Trolling - The Validity of the Discovery Rule at StakeSupreme Court petition challenges the validity of the 'discovery rule' for copyright claims. Stakeholders like NBA teams voice concerns over potential risks.
Discovery, Injury, and Diligence: Reconciling Subjective and Objective Copyright Limitations Standards Post-Warner ChappellThe Supreme Court may resolve a key issue regarding the statute of limitations for copyright infringement, potentially transforming copyright law.
Sheet Music v. Sound Waves: When Old Copyright Law Meets Modern MusicThe Ed Sheeran copyright dispute raises important questions about judicial deference and copyright scope under the 1909 Act.
The Briefing: NBA Teams Fight Back Against Trolling - The Validity of the Discovery Rule at StakeSupreme Court petition challenges the validity of the 'discovery rule' for copyright claims. Stakeholders like NBA teams voice concerns over potential risks.
Discovery, Injury, and Diligence: Reconciling Subjective and Objective Copyright Limitations Standards Post-Warner ChappellThe Supreme Court may resolve a key issue regarding the statute of limitations for copyright infringement, potentially transforming copyright law.
UK newspapers blanket their covers to protest loss of AI protectionsThe 'Make It Fair' campaign protests UK copyright updates that may permit AI companies to use protected creative works without permission.
Legends of screen and music among artists to protest copyright law changes to AIProposed changes to UK copyright law regarding AI are opposed by notable artists who claim it will harm the creative industry.
How Copyright Laws Apply to AI Assisted Creations - U.S. Copyright OfficeThe U.S. Copyright Office states that AI-generated works without meaningful human creative input are not eligible for copyright protection.
Copyright Office suggests AI copyright debate was settled in 1965AI-generated works cannot be copyrighted due to lack of sufficient human involvement, while AI-assisted works can be copyrightable depending on human creative input.
D.C. Circuit Upholds Human Authorship Requirement in Thaler v. PerlmutterThe D.C. Circuit upheld that only humans can be considered authors under the Copyright Act.
MPs: Ministers must give protections to creative sector amid AI copyright fearsAI poses copyright challenges that need legal addressing to protect creatives.Legislation is being considered to hold AI companies accountable for copyright use.
UK newspapers blanket their covers to protest loss of AI protectionsThe 'Make It Fair' campaign protests UK copyright updates that may permit AI companies to use protected creative works without permission.
Legends of screen and music among artists to protest copyright law changes to AIProposed changes to UK copyright law regarding AI are opposed by notable artists who claim it will harm the creative industry.
How Copyright Laws Apply to AI Assisted Creations - U.S. Copyright OfficeThe U.S. Copyright Office states that AI-generated works without meaningful human creative input are not eligible for copyright protection.
Copyright Office suggests AI copyright debate was settled in 1965AI-generated works cannot be copyrighted due to lack of sufficient human involvement, while AI-assisted works can be copyrightable depending on human creative input.
D.C. Circuit Upholds Human Authorship Requirement in Thaler v. PerlmutterThe D.C. Circuit upheld that only humans can be considered authors under the Copyright Act.
MPs: Ministers must give protections to creative sector amid AI copyright fearsAI poses copyright challenges that need legal addressing to protect creatives.Legislation is being considered to hold AI companies accountable for copyright use.
Google Faces Ad Tech Lawsuit in Australia; UK Gov Proposes Exception to Copyright Law for AI Training; EU Opens Proceedings Against TikTok on Election RisksGoogle is under scrutiny for monopolistic practices in ad tech in Australia.UK proposes changes to copyright laws to clarify AI training rights.EU takes action against TikTok regarding election-related risks.
Google says its European 'experiment' shows news is worthless to its ad businessGoogle's test shows EU news content holds little monetary value for its ad revenue, aiming to strengthen its position in negotiations with publishers.
Google claims news is worthless to its ad business after test involving 1% of search results in eight EU markets | TechCrunchGoogle conducted an experiment showing that news content has negligible value to its ad business, affecting its negotiations with publishers.
Google Faces Ad Tech Lawsuit in Australia; UK Gov Proposes Exception to Copyright Law for AI Training; EU Opens Proceedings Against TikTok on Election RisksGoogle is under scrutiny for monopolistic practices in ad tech in Australia.UK proposes changes to copyright laws to clarify AI training rights.EU takes action against TikTok regarding election-related risks.
Google says its European 'experiment' shows news is worthless to its ad businessGoogle's test shows EU news content holds little monetary value for its ad revenue, aiming to strengthen its position in negotiations with publishers.
Google claims news is worthless to its ad business after test involving 1% of search results in eight EU markets | TechCrunchGoogle conducted an experiment showing that news content has negligible value to its ad business, affecting its negotiations with publishers.
How Appealing Weekly Roundup - Above the LawThe article highlights significant developments in appellate litigation and legal interpretations related to copyright, immigration, and the judiciary under the Trump administration.
Judge: Mariah Carey didn't steal 'All I Want For Christmas Is You' from other writersMariah Carey won a legal victory over copyright claims regarding her hit song 'All I Want for Christmas Is You', preventing a trial.
1,000 artists release silent AI protest album Is This What We Want?Over 1,000 artists protest UK copyright law changes through a silent album, emphasizing potential harm to musicians from unlicensed AI utilization.
UK creatives protest AI copyright law changes with silent album and campaignCreative protest against UK government's copyright law changes by musicians highlights potential negative impact on their livelihood.
Paul McCartney calls on UK government to protect artists from AI | TechCrunchPaul McCartney warns against proposed UK copyright changes that threaten the economic rights of artists and musicians.
Miley Cyrus loses bid to dismiss lawsuit alleging 'Flowers' copied Bruno Mars hit 'When I Was Your Man'Miley Cyrus's lawsuit dismissal bid failed, allowing copyright claims on her song 'Flowers' against Bruno Mars' 'When I Was Your Man' to proceed.
'Double Shot' Of Justice: Artist Termination Rights Go Global - Above the LawModern copyright law must adapt to the global nature of art and music distribution, especially regarding termination rights.
1,000 artists release silent AI protest album Is This What We Want?Over 1,000 artists protest UK copyright law changes through a silent album, emphasizing potential harm to musicians from unlicensed AI utilization.
UK creatives protest AI copyright law changes with silent album and campaignCreative protest against UK government's copyright law changes by musicians highlights potential negative impact on their livelihood.
Paul McCartney calls on UK government to protect artists from AI | TechCrunchPaul McCartney warns against proposed UK copyright changes that threaten the economic rights of artists and musicians.
Miley Cyrus loses bid to dismiss lawsuit alleging 'Flowers' copied Bruno Mars hit 'When I Was Your Man'Miley Cyrus's lawsuit dismissal bid failed, allowing copyright claims on her song 'Flowers' against Bruno Mars' 'When I Was Your Man' to proceed.
'Double Shot' Of Justice: Artist Termination Rights Go Global - Above the LawModern copyright law must adapt to the global nature of art and music distribution, especially regarding termination rights.
Judge disses Star Trek icon Data's poetry while ruling AI can't author worksMachines cannot be considered authors under current copyright law.Judges emphasize human characteristics as essential for authorship in copyright.Legal definitions and implications of authorship must consider the nature of machines.
Copyright and AI: the Cases and the ConsequencesThe legal battles over model training highlight the tension between copyright protection and fair use, impacting future automation and creativity.
OpenAI declares AI race "over" if training on copyrighted works isn't fair useOpenAI seeks to establish AI training as fair use to enable access to copyrighted materials critical for competition against China.
AI company Ross Intelligence loses copyright fight with Thomson ReutersA judge ruled that Ross Intelligence cannot use Thomson Reuters' Westlaw content for AI training, impacting future copyright cases.
Don't buy Big Tech's 'we need to steal to beat China in AI' bullBig Tech companies are seeking to relax copyright laws to use copyrighted materials for AI training without compensation.
Getty Images CEO: Respecting fair use rules won't prevent AI from curing cancerThe debate over AI training on copyrighted materials is intensifying, highlighting clashes between technology firms and the rights of content creators.
How the Internet Archive's "Free Digital Library" fell to the "fair use" testThe Internet Archive's mission to provide free digital access faces legal challenges due to copyright violations.
Copyright and AI: the Cases and the ConsequencesThe legal battles over model training highlight the tension between copyright protection and fair use, impacting future automation and creativity.
OpenAI declares AI race "over" if training on copyrighted works isn't fair useOpenAI seeks to establish AI training as fair use to enable access to copyrighted materials critical for competition against China.
AI company Ross Intelligence loses copyright fight with Thomson ReutersA judge ruled that Ross Intelligence cannot use Thomson Reuters' Westlaw content for AI training, impacting future copyright cases.
Don't buy Big Tech's 'we need to steal to beat China in AI' bullBig Tech companies are seeking to relax copyright laws to use copyrighted materials for AI training without compensation.
Getty Images CEO: Respecting fair use rules won't prevent AI from curing cancerThe debate over AI training on copyrighted materials is intensifying, highlighting clashes between technology firms and the rights of content creators.
How the Internet Archive's "Free Digital Library" fell to the "fair use" testThe Internet Archive's mission to provide free digital access faces legal challenges due to copyright violations.
Brave wants court to endorse scraping of News Corp contentBrave's legal action seeks to protect its AI summaries from potential copyright claims by News Corp.
OpenAI wants all the data and for US law to apply everywhereOpenAI is seeking government support for AI development by promoting fair use copyright laws and opposing restrictive regulations from foreign entities.
Canadian media companies sue ChatGPTThe lawsuit's central issue revolves around copyright infringement and the ownership of digital content by news organizations.
OpenAI whistleblower found dead in San Francisco apartment | TechCrunchSuchir Balaji, a former OpenAI employee, was found dead in his apartment, with the death ruled a suicide.
OpenAI opposes data deletion demand in India citing US legal constraintsThe lawsuit against OpenAI highlights challenges in AI regulation and copyright issues faced by developers.
OpenAI whistleblower found dead by apparent suicideBalaji's death was ruled a suicide, raising concerns over mental health in tech.Concerns about copyright infringement in AI training have been highlighted by Balaji's writings.
Raw Story v. OpenAI: The Constitutional Hurdle That Tripped Up Raw Story's AI LawsuitThe dismissal of Raw Story v. OpenAI highlights challenges in anti-AI copyright claims under DMCA's CMI provisions.
OpenAI wants all the data and for US law to apply everywhereOpenAI is seeking government support for AI development by promoting fair use copyright laws and opposing restrictive regulations from foreign entities.
Canadian media companies sue ChatGPTThe lawsuit's central issue revolves around copyright infringement and the ownership of digital content by news organizations.
OpenAI whistleblower found dead in San Francisco apartment | TechCrunchSuchir Balaji, a former OpenAI employee, was found dead in his apartment, with the death ruled a suicide.
OpenAI opposes data deletion demand in India citing US legal constraintsThe lawsuit against OpenAI highlights challenges in AI regulation and copyright issues faced by developers.
OpenAI whistleblower found dead by apparent suicideBalaji's death was ruled a suicide, raising concerns over mental health in tech.Concerns about copyright infringement in AI training have been highlighted by Balaji's writings.
Raw Story v. OpenAI: The Constitutional Hurdle That Tripped Up Raw Story's AI LawsuitThe dismissal of Raw Story v. OpenAI highlights challenges in anti-AI copyright claims under DMCA's CMI provisions.
The Guardian view on AI and copyright: creativity should be cherished, not given away | EditorialThe UK government faces pressure to relax copyright laws for AI development despite the potential risks to creative rights and protections.
No Infringement of Nonfiction Work by Makers of Tetris Film - Court Uses Wrong Analysis to Reach the Right ResultThe author of a non-fiction work cannot claim copyright over historical facts, only the expression of those facts.
Can sandals be art? Birkenstock says yes, but a German court says noGermany's Federal Court ruled that Birkenstock sandals do not qualify as art and are simply comfortable footwear.
can AI art be copyrighted? not if there's no human input, US office saysAI art copyright requires human input; fully AI-generated works are not copyrightable.The US Copyright Office clarifies that human contributions determine authorship in AI art.
Key IP Issues for the Next President and Congress to Tackle: AI and Patent Subject Matter EligibilityThe next administration is expected to focus on addressing IP law issues related to AI, including deepfakes and copyright for AI training.
Nintendo Lawyer Explains Why The Company Believes Some Emulators Are IllegalNintendo is actively combating emulation and piracy to protect its intellectual property rights.
The Guardian view on AI and copyright: creativity should be cherished, not given away | EditorialThe UK government faces pressure to relax copyright laws for AI development despite the potential risks to creative rights and protections.
No Infringement of Nonfiction Work by Makers of Tetris Film - Court Uses Wrong Analysis to Reach the Right ResultThe author of a non-fiction work cannot claim copyright over historical facts, only the expression of those facts.
Can sandals be art? Birkenstock says yes, but a German court says noGermany's Federal Court ruled that Birkenstock sandals do not qualify as art and are simply comfortable footwear.
can AI art be copyrighted? not if there's no human input, US office saysAI art copyright requires human input; fully AI-generated works are not copyrightable.The US Copyright Office clarifies that human contributions determine authorship in AI art.
Key IP Issues for the Next President and Congress to Tackle: AI and Patent Subject Matter EligibilityThe next administration is expected to focus on addressing IP law issues related to AI, including deepfakes and copyright for AI training.
Nintendo Lawyer Explains Why The Company Believes Some Emulators Are IllegalNintendo is actively combating emulation and piracy to protect its intellectual property rights.
The U.S. Copyright Office, GenAI, and the Advancement of CultureThe USCO's 2023 guidelines address copyrightability by emphasizing the necessity of human contribution in AI-assisted works.
US Copyright Office: generative AI art requires 'human authorship' for protectionU.S. Copyright Office states AI-generated works without human authorship won't receive copyright protection.
The U.S. Copyright Office, GenAI, and the Advancement of CultureThe USCO's 2023 guidelines address copyrightability by emphasizing the necessity of human contribution in AI-assisted works.
US Copyright Office: generative AI art requires 'human authorship' for protectionU.S. Copyright Office states AI-generated works without human authorship won't receive copyright protection.
AI copyright plans would be undemocratic own goal', says Sir Cameron MackintoshProposed changes to copyright law for AI use threaten creators' rights, as criticized by influential figures like Sir Cameron Mackintosh.
1,000 artists release 'silent' album to protest UK copyright sell-out to AI | TechCrunchMusicians in the U.K. are protesting copyright law changes that would enable the use of their work for AI training without compensation.
The Briefing: Westlaw v. Ross AI - Is This The End of AI Training or The Future of AI TrainingDelaware court ruling in Thomson Reuters v. Ross AI may reshape AI training and copyright law.Impact on AI developers could constrain innovation due to potential licensing requirements.
Tech Secretary will not be forced' to choose one side in AI copyright debateSupporting independent journalism is crucial for factual reporting on important issues like reproductive rights, climate change, and AI.
UK government looks to rewrite copyright rules for AI training | Computer WeeklyGovernment consultation aims to establish an AI exception in UK copyright law for better rights management in the creative industries.
Morning Docket: 01.30.25 - Above the LawAI's potential threat to humanity contrasts with its inability to challenge copyright powerhouses.Illegal streaming may not drive meaningful copyright reform despite ongoing discussions.
AI copyright plans would be undemocratic own goal', says Sir Cameron MackintoshProposed changes to copyright law for AI use threaten creators' rights, as criticized by influential figures like Sir Cameron Mackintosh.
1,000 artists release 'silent' album to protest UK copyright sell-out to AI | TechCrunchMusicians in the U.K. are protesting copyright law changes that would enable the use of their work for AI training without compensation.
The Briefing: Westlaw v. Ross AI - Is This The End of AI Training or The Future of AI TrainingDelaware court ruling in Thomson Reuters v. Ross AI may reshape AI training and copyright law.Impact on AI developers could constrain innovation due to potential licensing requirements.
Tech Secretary will not be forced' to choose one side in AI copyright debateSupporting independent journalism is crucial for factual reporting on important issues like reproductive rights, climate change, and AI.
UK government looks to rewrite copyright rules for AI training | Computer WeeklyGovernment consultation aims to establish an AI exception in UK copyright law for better rights management in the creative industries.
Morning Docket: 01.30.25 - Above the LawAI's potential threat to humanity contrasts with its inability to challenge copyright powerhouses.Illegal streaming may not drive meaningful copyright reform despite ongoing discussions.
Licence to kill: could a James Bond horror emerge when book copyrights expire?James Bond's original literary works will enter public domain in 2035, allowing competitors to create new adaptations.
Popeye, Tintin and more will enter the public domain in the new yearPopeye and Tintin enter public domain in 2025, opening the door for new adaptations and creative expression from classic works.
Licence to kill: could a James Bond horror emerge when book copyrights expire?James Bond's original literary works will enter public domain in 2035, allowing competitors to create new adaptations.
Popeye, Tintin and more will enter the public domain in the new yearPopeye and Tintin enter public domain in 2025, opening the door for new adaptations and creative expression from classic works.
Copyright-infringement lawsuit over Jeff Koons's infamous Made in Heaven series is dismissedThe lawsuit against Jeff Koons was dismissed due to the plaintiff's delayed claim of copyright infringement.
I don't want a fight': the Brazilian samba composer suing Adele for plagiarismAdele's absence from a Brazilian copyright hearing on alleged plagiarism of a samba song underscores legal complexities in music copyright.
Copyright-infringement lawsuit over Jeff Koons's infamous Made in Heaven series is dismissedThe lawsuit against Jeff Koons was dismissed due to the plaintiff's delayed claim of copyright infringement.
I don't want a fight': the Brazilian samba composer suing Adele for plagiarismAdele's absence from a Brazilian copyright hearing on alleged plagiarism of a samba song underscores legal complexities in music copyright.
The Briefing: Federal District Court Adopts Problematic "Vibe Copyright" Protection in Influencer FightCopyright law can protect certain vibes and aesthetics, impacting content creators and brands.
Musical AI and Beatoven.ai Pioneer a Fully Licensed Generative AI Music Platform | stupidDOPEAI in music can be ethical and sustainable.Musical AI and Beatoven.ai create a licensed generative AI music platform.
Clock is Ticking for Responses to UK Government Consultation on Copyright and Artificial IntelligenceThe UK government is considering changes to copyright laws regarding the use of works in training generative AI models.
Musical AI and Beatoven.ai Pioneer a Fully Licensed Generative AI Music Platform | stupidDOPEAI in music can be ethical and sustainable.Musical AI and Beatoven.ai create a licensed generative AI music platform.
Clock is Ticking for Responses to UK Government Consultation on Copyright and Artificial IntelligenceThe UK government is considering changes to copyright laws regarding the use of works in training generative AI models.
Other Barks and Bites for Friday, January 17: Teva Files IRA Challenge amid Second Round of Medicare Negotiations; Ninth Circuit Says Kinetic Sculptures Can Be Sufficiently 'Fixed' for Copyright; Second Circuit Affirms DMCA Safe Harbor Win for VimeoThe legal landscape around copyright and patents is evolving, driven by court decisions and regulatory actions.
Elizabeth Goodspeed on what happens when we treat the past like a stock libraryCopyright law is complex and often favors corporations over individual artists.
Other Barks and Bites for Friday, January 17: Teva Files IRA Challenge amid Second Round of Medicare Negotiations; Ninth Circuit Says Kinetic Sculptures Can Be Sufficiently 'Fixed' for Copyright; Second Circuit Affirms DMCA Safe Harbor Win for VimeoThe legal landscape around copyright and patents is evolving, driven by court decisions and regulatory actions.
Elizabeth Goodspeed on what happens when we treat the past like a stock libraryCopyright law is complex and often favors corporations over individual artists.
James Gunn's Superman Tied Up in Super LawsuitJoe Shuster's estate is suing DC Comics for copyright infringement regarding Superman, potentially impacting upcoming projects.
Character.AI Confirms Mass Deletion of Fandom Characters, Says They're Not Coming BackCharacter.AI has removed numerous character bots due to copyright law issues, impacting user engagement and enjoyment.
James Gunn's Superman Tied Up in Super LawsuitJoe Shuster's estate is suing DC Comics for copyright infringement regarding Superman, potentially impacting upcoming projects.
Character.AI Confirms Mass Deletion of Fandom Characters, Says They're Not Coming BackCharacter.AI has removed numerous character bots due to copyright law issues, impacting user engagement and enjoyment.
Attorney Fees in Copyright Cases, Part IIVoluntary dismissal in copyright cases raises complex questions about 'prevailing party' status and attorney fees under the Copyright Act.
Voluntary Dismissals and Attorney FeesThe interpretation of attorney fees in copyright and patent cases is influenced by circuit splits regarding voluntary dismissals and prevailing party status.
Attorney Fees in Copyright Cases, Part IIVoluntary dismissal in copyright cases raises complex questions about 'prevailing party' status and attorney fees under the Copyright Act.
Voluntary Dismissals and Attorney FeesThe interpretation of attorney fees in copyright and patent cases is influenced by circuit splits regarding voluntary dismissals and prevailing party status.
SCOTUS Tells Steve King To Go Away In 'Success Kid' Case Over Legal Fees - Above the LawSteve King's campaign faced copyright infringement for using the 'Success Kid' meme, highlighting tensions between copyright law and personal values.
The Shoptimist: An advertisement in influencer's clothingSydney Gifford's lawsuit against fellow influencer Alyssa Sheil could redefine copyright in the context of social media aesthetics.
What Proponents of Digital Replica Laws Can Learn from the Digital Millennium Copyright ActConcerns over AI replacing creators have led to problematic legislative proposals that could exacerbate censorship online rather than protect artistic expression.
Meta Secretly Trained Its AI on a Notorious Russian 'Shadow Library,' Newly Unredacted Court Docs RevealMeta's alleged use of the LibGen dataset, known to be pirated, is central to the ongoing lawsuit against the tech giant.
Second Circuit Rejects Record Labels' Attempt to Rewrite the DMCAVimeo won a significant legal victory reaffirming the protections for user-generated content under the DMCA's safe harbor provisions.
Meta Secretly Trained Its AI on a Notorious Russian 'Shadow Library,' Newly Unredacted Court Docs RevealMeta's alleged use of the LibGen dataset, known to be pirated, is central to the ongoing lawsuit against the tech giant.
Second Circuit Rejects Record Labels' Attempt to Rewrite the DMCAVimeo won a significant legal victory reaffirming the protections for user-generated content under the DMCA's safe harbor provisions.
Why We Celebrate When Copyright ExpiresPublic Domain Day celebrates the expiration of copyright on many works, allowing for creative freedom and reinterpretation.
'Nosferatu' Keeps You Waiting And Waiting | DefectorFlorence Stoker's legal battle over 'Nosferatu' highlights issues of copyright and artistic adaptation stemming from Bram Stoker's original 'Dracula.'
These Startups Are Making Sure AI Companies Pay Up For Taking ContentMedia companies are adapting by using middlemen to license content to AI businesses.Emerging firms provide solutions to get compensated for AI scraping their content.
Ninth Circuit Gets It: Interoperability Isn't an Automatic First Step to LiabilityThe federal appellate court's ruling supports software developers' ability to create updates for interoperability, fostering innovation and competition.
The Stack: UK Gov Addresses Developers' AI Training Rights and Introduces New Online Safety Regulations for Big Tech - ExchangeWire.comThe UK government is proposing new regulations for AI content training and online safety, facing pushback from creative industries.
There's No Copyright Exception to First Amendment Protections for Anonymous SpeechThe First Amendment protects anonymous discussions regarding illegal activities, including copyright infringement, and courts have repeatedly denied attempts to unmask such speakers.
In Steve McQueen's Blitz, We're Going Underground, Going UndergroundSteve McQueen's new film offers traditional storytelling but provokes debate about its cultural impact; HBO's Get Millie Black intertwines rich narratives with predictable elements.Legal challenges facing lifestyle influencers overview essential for the future of online commerce.
UMG sues Warner-owned Believe, parent of TuneCore, claiming infringementUMG accuses Believe of profiting from distributing infringing audio tracks, altering metadata, and wrongfully collecting royalties, seeking $500 million in damages.
Warner Brothers' Max Arrives to Asia; Indian News Agency Sues OpenAI; Havas to Consider M&AsWarner Brothers' Max streaming service is leveraging Hollywood content and local partnerships for entry into Asian markets.
UMG sues Warner-owned Believe, parent of TuneCore, claiming infringementUMG accuses Believe of profiting from distributing infringing audio tracks, altering metadata, and wrongfully collecting royalties, seeking $500 million in damages.
Warner Brothers' Max Arrives to Asia; Indian News Agency Sues OpenAI; Havas to Consider M&AsWarner Brothers' Max streaming service is leveraging Hollywood content and local partnerships for entry into Asian markets.
Second Circuit Finds Marvin Gaye and Ed Sheeran Similarities Too Unoriginal for Copyright ProtectionThe Second Circuit ruled that Ed Sheeran's song did not infringe on copyright because the musical components were too unoriginal for protection.