No Provisional Rights for Expired PatentsA Federal Circuit decision rules against granting a patent that would expire upon issuance, emphasizing jurisdictional limitations on appeals.Provisional rights under patent law provide some back-pay for infringement but only take effect post-issuance.
Federal Circuit Tells Patent Applicant Expired Patents Don't Get Provisional Rights EitherPatentees cannot claim provisional rights if a patent issues after its expiration date.
No Provisional Rights for Expired PatentsA Federal Circuit decision rules against granting a patent that would expire upon issuance, emphasizing jurisdictional limitations on appeals.Provisional rights under patent law provide some back-pay for infringement but only take effect post-issuance.
Federal Circuit Tells Patent Applicant Expired Patents Don't Get Provisional Rights EitherPatentees cannot claim provisional rights if a patent issues after its expiration date.
IPWatchdog LIVE 2025 Panel Explores Global IP TrendsEmerging markets are making significant strides in their intellectual property regimes, according to recent evaluations.The U.S. is still a leader in IP efficiency, but emerging markets show noteworthy progress.
Supreme Court Denies Cert on Section 101, Fraudulent Procurement of Trademark PetitionsThe U.S. Supreme Court denied petitions for clarity on Section 101 patent eligibility, impacting Impact Engine's appeal regarding web-based advertisement systems.
EcoFactor v. Google: Quick Review of Oral ArgumentsThe Federal Circuit is reviewing how courts assess expert testimony related to patent damages.
Inventor Cites Notice Withdrawing USPTO's Fintiv Memo as 'Significant Authority' in Her Case Against Big Tech CompaniesHafeman's appeal focuses on the PTAB's failure to enforce a Sotera stipulation rather than the Fintiv analysis applied during IPR.
Convergence: Island IP Points to Wave of Rule 36 PetitionsIsland Intellectual Property seeks Supreme Court review of Federal Circuit practices regarding summary judgment standards and Rule 36 affirmances.
Inside the Beltway: The Future of U.S. IP Policy in the Trump AdministrationSignificant shifts in intellectual property policy are expected with Trump back in office.Protecting American innovation and ensuring U.S. technological leadership are key priorities under the Trump administration.
IPWatchdog LIVE 2025 Panel Explores Global IP TrendsEmerging markets are making significant strides in their intellectual property regimes, according to recent evaluations.The U.S. is still a leader in IP efficiency, but emerging markets show noteworthy progress.
Supreme Court Denies Cert on Section 101, Fraudulent Procurement of Trademark PetitionsThe U.S. Supreme Court denied petitions for clarity on Section 101 patent eligibility, impacting Impact Engine's appeal regarding web-based advertisement systems.
EcoFactor v. Google: Quick Review of Oral ArgumentsThe Federal Circuit is reviewing how courts assess expert testimony related to patent damages.
Inventor Cites Notice Withdrawing USPTO's Fintiv Memo as 'Significant Authority' in Her Case Against Big Tech CompaniesHafeman's appeal focuses on the PTAB's failure to enforce a Sotera stipulation rather than the Fintiv analysis applied during IPR.
Convergence: Island IP Points to Wave of Rule 36 PetitionsIsland Intellectual Property seeks Supreme Court review of Federal Circuit practices regarding summary judgment standards and Rule 36 affirmances.
Inside the Beltway: The Future of U.S. IP Policy in the Trump AdministrationSignificant shifts in intellectual property policy are expected with Trump back in office.Protecting American innovation and ensuring U.S. technological leadership are key priorities under the Trump administration.
Google Dodges Supreme Court Review of Its Ad Tech Patent WinThe US Supreme Court upheld a ruling that reinforces the framework for abstract ideas in patent law.
How District Courts Are Approaching Alice's Failure to Define 'Abstract Ideas'The courts are correctly applying the evidentiary burden for determining patent eligibility under the Alice standard.
Impact Engine is Latest to Ask SCOTUS to Fix Federal Circuit's Alice AnalysisImpact Engine petitions SCOTUS to clarify standards for means-plus-function claims and address patent eligibility under Section 101.
Google Dodges Supreme Court Review of Its Ad Tech Patent WinThe US Supreme Court upheld a ruling that reinforces the framework for abstract ideas in patent law.
How District Courts Are Approaching Alice's Failure to Define 'Abstract Ideas'The courts are correctly applying the evidentiary burden for determining patent eligibility under the Alice standard.
Impact Engine is Latest to Ask SCOTUS to Fix Federal Circuit's Alice AnalysisImpact Engine petitions SCOTUS to clarify standards for means-plus-function claims and address patent eligibility under Section 101.
Patent Law Year in Review: Top-Nine Topics for 2025The U.S. patent landscape is shifting dramatically with changes in administration, impacting policies and the backlog of patents.Key court decisions are reshaping design patent analysis towards flexibility, responding to evolving global standards.
IP News from IPWatchdog: Barks & Bites for Friday, March 14The Federal Circuit reaffirmed principles of claim separateness in a recent patent case, impacting how injunctions may be filed.Major leadership changes occurred in the Copyright Office and the USPTO amidst ongoing legislative actions.
CAFC Says Patent Applicant Failed to Timely Preserve Appointments Clause Challenge to Examiner RejectionThe Federal Circuit affirmed the dismissal of Odyssey Logistics' Appointments Clause challenge due to untimely preservation of the challenge.
Federal Circuit Denies Patent Agent Registration for Former USPTO Examiner Who Failed to Disclose Workplace SuspensionIntegrity and transparency are critical in legal professional registration processes.
New USPTO Leadership on the Horizon: Lutnick Confirmed as Commerce Secretary, Squires Expected as DirectorHoward Lutnick confirmed as Secretary of Commerce; John Squires expected to be nominated as USPTO Director with strong IP experience.
Diamond Art Club Challenges USPTO's Mass Termination of Chinese-Origin Applications in Federal CourtThe USPTO terminated 3,100 patent applications due to signature fraud by a non-registered practitioner.
Patent Law Year in Review: Top-Nine Topics for 2025The U.S. patent landscape is shifting dramatically with changes in administration, impacting policies and the backlog of patents.Key court decisions are reshaping design patent analysis towards flexibility, responding to evolving global standards.
IP News from IPWatchdog: Barks & Bites for Friday, March 14The Federal Circuit reaffirmed principles of claim separateness in a recent patent case, impacting how injunctions may be filed.Major leadership changes occurred in the Copyright Office and the USPTO amidst ongoing legislative actions.
CAFC Says Patent Applicant Failed to Timely Preserve Appointments Clause Challenge to Examiner RejectionThe Federal Circuit affirmed the dismissal of Odyssey Logistics' Appointments Clause challenge due to untimely preservation of the challenge.
Federal Circuit Denies Patent Agent Registration for Former USPTO Examiner Who Failed to Disclose Workplace SuspensionIntegrity and transparency are critical in legal professional registration processes.
New USPTO Leadership on the Horizon: Lutnick Confirmed as Commerce Secretary, Squires Expected as DirectorHoward Lutnick confirmed as Secretary of Commerce; John Squires expected to be nominated as USPTO Director with strong IP experience.
Diamond Art Club Challenges USPTO's Mass Termination of Chinese-Origin Applications in Federal CourtThe USPTO terminated 3,100 patent applications due to signature fraud by a non-registered practitioner.
Ninth Circuit Rejects Patent Misuse Defense in Minimum Royalty Dispute, Setting Up Potential Supreme Court ReviewPatent misuse disputes can arise in contexts beyond the Federal Circuit's jurisdiction, as seen in C.R. Bard, Inc. v. Atrium Medical Corp.
Estoppel Timing and Procedural Traps in Patent ChallengesThe Federal Circuit affirmed mixed results from the IPRs related to Gesture Technology's patent case against major tech companies.
Federal Circuit Clarifies 101 Patent Eligibility for Composition-of-Matter ClaimsFederal Circuit reversed ITC ruling, affirming patent eligibility of claims related to polycrystalline diamond compacts.This ruling provides important clarity for patent owners regarding patent eligibility challenges under Section 101.
The Last Word: ParkerVision's Reply Brief Makes Final Push for Supreme Court Review of Rule 36The Supreme Court may review R.36 cases questioning the Federal Circuit's one-word judgments without explanation.
The Doctrinal Merger No One Asked For: How Enablement Swallowed UtilityThe Full Scope Enablement Doctrine is transforming the evaluation of utility requirements in patent claims.
CAFC Says Prior Art Requires Written Support in Jepson Claim RulingThe Federal Circuit's ruling suggests that Jepson claims without prior art support are invalid, impacting their future use drastically.
Ninth Circuit Rejects Patent Misuse Defense in Minimum Royalty Dispute, Setting Up Potential Supreme Court ReviewPatent misuse disputes can arise in contexts beyond the Federal Circuit's jurisdiction, as seen in C.R. Bard, Inc. v. Atrium Medical Corp.
Estoppel Timing and Procedural Traps in Patent ChallengesThe Federal Circuit affirmed mixed results from the IPRs related to Gesture Technology's patent case against major tech companies.
Federal Circuit Clarifies 101 Patent Eligibility for Composition-of-Matter ClaimsFederal Circuit reversed ITC ruling, affirming patent eligibility of claims related to polycrystalline diamond compacts.This ruling provides important clarity for patent owners regarding patent eligibility challenges under Section 101.
The Last Word: ParkerVision's Reply Brief Makes Final Push for Supreme Court Review of Rule 36The Supreme Court may review R.36 cases questioning the Federal Circuit's one-word judgments without explanation.
The Doctrinal Merger No One Asked For: How Enablement Swallowed UtilityThe Full Scope Enablement Doctrine is transforming the evaluation of utility requirements in patent claims.
CAFC Says Prior Art Requires Written Support in Jepson Claim RulingThe Federal Circuit's ruling suggests that Jepson claims without prior art support are invalid, impacting their future use drastically.
PatCon 13, April 10-12PatCon 13 is the largest annual patent conference, featuring keynotes and awards for leaders in patent law.The event is free for academics, students, and government attorneys.
Federal Court Partially Blocks Executive Order Targeting WilmerHale: USPTO Acting Director Among Named DefendantsJudge Leon partially granted WilmerHale's motion, protecting First Amendment rights against President Trump's executive order.
Statutory Text vs. Precedent: Analyzing the AIA's On-Sale Bar for Secret Processes in Celanese v. ITCThe Celanese v. ITC case examines whether selling products made from a secret process triggers the on-sale bar under revised patent law.
Federal Circuit Clarifies Anticipation Analysis for Product-By-Process ClaimsThe Federal Circuit upheld that the '176 patent was not inherently anticipated by prior art due to lack of proof of inevitable marker expression.
CAFC Rules Provisional Application Must Support Portion of Non-Provisional Cited in Rejection to Claim Earlier Priority DateThe CAFC clarified that provisional applications need to support specific patent specifications for prior art rejections.
Federal Circuit Clarifies Anticipation Analysis for Product-By-Process ClaimsThe Federal Circuit upheld that the '176 patent was not inherently anticipated by prior art due to lack of proof of inevitable marker expression.
CAFC Rules Provisional Application Must Support Portion of Non-Provisional Cited in Rejection to Claim Earlier Priority DateThe CAFC clarified that provisional applications need to support specific patent specifications for prior art rejections.
Prosecution Disclaimer Across Patent Family MembersProsecution history should not broadly limit claims across patent families without clear similarities.
Harrity & Harrity, LLP is Seeking a Patent Drafting Professional (Remote, Within US) - IPWatchdog.com | Patents & Intellectual Property LawHarrity & Harrity, LLP is hiring experienced patent attorneys or agents for a remote, flexible position in patent drafting.
Other Barks & Bites for Friday, March 7: Lashify Wins ITC Appeal on Economic Prong Analysis; CAFC Says Apple Did Not Violate Discovery Obligations at PTAB; and ParkerVision Files Reply Brief on Rule 36 Appeal at SCOTUSFederal Circuit clarified discovery obligations for IPR petitioners.Broadcom's AI chip demand positively impacted their Q1 results.Novo Nordisk is leading in anti-obesity drug patents.REPAIR Act aims to enhance automotive consumer rights.
Can State Law Contracts Limit the Right to Repair Even When Patent Protections Exhaust?The right to repair under U.S. patent law is broad but faces challenges from contractual limitations.
Other Barks & Bites for Friday, March 7: Lashify Wins ITC Appeal on Economic Prong Analysis; CAFC Says Apple Did Not Violate Discovery Obligations at PTAB; and ParkerVision Files Reply Brief on Rule 36 Appeal at SCOTUSFederal Circuit clarified discovery obligations for IPR petitioners.Broadcom's AI chip demand positively impacted their Q1 results.Novo Nordisk is leading in anti-obesity drug patents.REPAIR Act aims to enhance automotive consumer rights.
Can State Law Contracts Limit the Right to Repair Even When Patent Protections Exhaust?The right to repair under U.S. patent law is broad but faces challenges from contractual limitations.
Reconsidering IPR Strategies in Light of Kroy IP Holdings v. GrouponThe Kroy IP ruling offers patent owners new strategic options for enforcement while challenging the approaches of IPR petitioners regarding claim assessment.
Federal Circuit offers Another Important Expansion of the Domestic Industry Requirement for USITC JurisdictionThe ITC protects U.S. industries from foreign patent infringement through exclusion orders and has a faster resolution process than district courts.
Settlement Licenses and Patent Marking: Intent of the Parties is KeyPatent marking requirements rely on the intentions expressed in settlement licenses between parties.Non-practicing entities must ensure licensees mark products to claim infringement damages.
Treading Carefully: How to Navigate the Common Law Research Exemption and the Hatch-Waxman Safe HarborThe common law experimental use exemption offers narrow protections against patent infringement, which poses challenges for scientific research activities.Courts are increasingly focused on the commercial implications of activities within the context of patent rights.
Federal Circuit offers Another Important Expansion of the Domestic Industry Requirement for USITC JurisdictionThe ITC protects U.S. industries from foreign patent infringement through exclusion orders and has a faster resolution process than district courts.
Settlement Licenses and Patent Marking: Intent of the Parties is KeyPatent marking requirements rely on the intentions expressed in settlement licenses between parties.Non-practicing entities must ensure licensees mark products to claim infringement damages.
Treading Carefully: How to Navigate the Common Law Research Exemption and the Hatch-Waxman Safe HarborThe common law experimental use exemption offers narrow protections against patent infringement, which poses challenges for scientific research activities.Courts are increasingly focused on the commercial implications of activities within the context of patent rights.
The Return of a Mandate on Patent Infringement Precludes Further Consideration of Issues Actually DecidedDistrict courts cannot reconsider issues already decided by appellate courts without specific instructions when the case is remanded.
Judge John Holcomb: Doing My Very Best to Get it RightThe success of IPWatchdog LIVE 2025 highlights the importance of in-person discussions within the patent law community.
Federal Circuit Affirms Partial Win for Patent Owner Against AppleThe CAFC upheld the PTAB's ruling on Gesture Technology's patent claims amidst Apple's appeal.Apple's arguments regarding obviousness and standing were rejected by the court.
Oral Hearings in UK Optis/Apple Global FRAND Case Indicate Justices Will Modify High Court RulingThe UK Court of Appeal is likely to adjust damages awarded to Optis in its ongoing patent dispute with Apple.
Apple Watch won't face import ban as Apple wins the AliveCor patent caseApple won a significant legal battle against AliveCor, preventing a potential import ban on Apple Watches with EKG sensors.
Federal Circuit Affirms Partial Win for Patent Owner Against AppleThe CAFC upheld the PTAB's ruling on Gesture Technology's patent claims amidst Apple's appeal.Apple's arguments regarding obviousness and standing were rejected by the court.
Oral Hearings in UK Optis/Apple Global FRAND Case Indicate Justices Will Modify High Court RulingThe UK Court of Appeal is likely to adjust damages awarded to Optis in its ongoing patent dispute with Apple.
Apple Watch won't face import ban as Apple wins the AliveCor patent caseApple won a significant legal battle against AliveCor, preventing a potential import ban on Apple Watches with EKG sensors.
CAFC Vacates PTAB's Finding that Meat Prep Patent Was ObviousThe CAFC ruled that the PTAB's decision is unclear and must adhere to the obviousness theory presented in the case.
Save Your Claims: How to Beat the PTAB's 70% All Claims Invalidation RateUnderstanding the differences between district court and PTAB is crucial for effective patent litigation.
CAFC Affirms PTAB's Obviousness Finding Despite Erroneous Claim ConstructionThe CAFC upheld the PTAB's decision, finding an erroneous claim interpretation that did not affect the outcome of the patent invalidation.
Legislation is Good, But the PTAB Needs a More Immediate OverhaulIPR provides a faster, cheaper alternative to district court litigation for patent validity assessments.
Patents and the Future of the USPTO in Trump's Second TermPatent reform discussions are heating up in anticipation of President Trump's second term, focusing on specific legislative changes affecting patent eligibility and enforcement.
CAFC Vacates PTAB's Finding that Meat Prep Patent Was ObviousThe CAFC ruled that the PTAB's decision is unclear and must adhere to the obviousness theory presented in the case.
Save Your Claims: How to Beat the PTAB's 70% All Claims Invalidation RateUnderstanding the differences between district court and PTAB is crucial for effective patent litigation.
CAFC Affirms PTAB's Obviousness Finding Despite Erroneous Claim ConstructionThe CAFC upheld the PTAB's decision, finding an erroneous claim interpretation that did not affect the outcome of the patent invalidation.
Legislation is Good, But the PTAB Needs a More Immediate OverhaulIPR provides a faster, cheaper alternative to district court litigation for patent validity assessments.
Patents and the Future of the USPTO in Trump's Second TermPatent reform discussions are heating up in anticipation of President Trump's second term, focusing on specific legislative changes affecting patent eligibility and enforcement.
Privilege Gone Too Far? How a 250-Year-Old Privilege Cost Atturo $10 MillionThe case highlights the need for Supreme Court clarification on Illinois' litigation privilege after a patent dispute.Atturo Tire Corp. seeks guidance from the Illinois Supreme Court after a controversial Federal Circuit ruling.
Generic Drugs, Skinny Labels, and Liability for Off Label (Infringing) UseHikma's petition seeks clarification on generic drug marketing liability regarding 'skinny labels' under patent law.
How Litigation Funding Allows Small Companies to Invest in Innovation Instead of LawyersLitigation funding can help small businesses enforce patent rights without draining core resources.
Other Barks & Bites for Friday, February 14: EU Commission Scraps SEP Draft Regulations; Senate Commerce to Explore Spectrum Auction Delays; House Science Seeks Review of Commercial Space LicensingThe European Commission has abandoned draft regulations on standard essential patents, a decision positively received by R&D firms.
How Litigation Funding Allows Small Companies to Invest in Innovation Instead of LawyersLitigation funding can help small businesses enforce patent rights without draining core resources.
Other Barks & Bites for Friday, February 14: EU Commission Scraps SEP Draft Regulations; Senate Commerce to Explore Spectrum Auction Delays; House Science Seeks Review of Commercial Space LicensingThe European Commission has abandoned draft regulations on standard essential patents, a decision positively received by R&D firms.
OpenSky Brief Raises Several APA, Constitutional Challenges to Vidal's Sanctions OrderOpenSky Industries is appealing sanctions by Director Kathi Vidal, arguing they violate administrative and constitutional law.
Blurring the Line Between Law and Fact in Patent EligibilityPatent law blurs the lines between law and fact, complicating eligibility analysis and evidentiary standards.