#patent-law

[ follow ]
#uspto

Why the Proposed Rule on Terminal Disclaimers Should Not Be Finalized

The USPTO should enhance examination practices for continuation applications while leaving policy decisions about patent thickets to Congress.

USPTO Makes Motion to Amend Pilot Permanent in Final Rule

The USPTO's final rule improves the Motion to Amend process, providing greater assurance of patentability evaluation before issuance.

Check your Patent Term Adjustments (PTA): What you Need to Know about the USPTO Error

The USPTO revealed a coding error affecting patent term adjustments for patents issued between March 19, 2024, and July 30, 2024.

USPTO's Final Rule on FY 2025 Patent Fees Drops Divisive Proposals for Across-the-Board Hikes

The USPTO announced a 7.5% fee increase while dropping highly controversial fee proposals from the April 2024 NPRM.

USPTO Terminates Thousands of Chinese Patent Applications Due to Forged Attorney/Agent Signatures

The USPTO ended 3,100 patent applications due to fraudulent signature use, impacting largely Chinese companies unfairly.

USPTO Timeliness Slipping: Patent Term Adjustment Data Shows Growing Examination Delays

The USPTO is struggling with timely processing of patent applications, evident from increased Patent Term Adjustment awards.

Why the Proposed Rule on Terminal Disclaimers Should Not Be Finalized

The USPTO should enhance examination practices for continuation applications while leaving policy decisions about patent thickets to Congress.

USPTO Makes Motion to Amend Pilot Permanent in Final Rule

The USPTO's final rule improves the Motion to Amend process, providing greater assurance of patentability evaluation before issuance.

Check your Patent Term Adjustments (PTA): What you Need to Know about the USPTO Error

The USPTO revealed a coding error affecting patent term adjustments for patents issued between March 19, 2024, and July 30, 2024.

USPTO's Final Rule on FY 2025 Patent Fees Drops Divisive Proposals for Across-the-Board Hikes

The USPTO announced a 7.5% fee increase while dropping highly controversial fee proposals from the April 2024 NPRM.

USPTO Terminates Thousands of Chinese Patent Applications Due to Forged Attorney/Agent Signatures

The USPTO ended 3,100 patent applications due to fraudulent signature use, impacting largely Chinese companies unfairly.

USPTO Timeliness Slipping: Patent Term Adjustment Data Shows Growing Examination Delays

The USPTO is struggling with timely processing of patent applications, evident from increased Patent Term Adjustment awards.
moreuspto
#federal-circuit

From Judge Markey's Promise to Rule 36: We Do Not Just Render One-Worded Decisions

The Supreme Court has an opportunity to address the Federal Circuit's use of no-opinion affirmances in patent appeals.

Checking in With Alice Part II: Takeaways and Predictions

The Federal Circuit is limiting patent eligibility for data processing and organizational claims, indicating a harsh landscape for software technologies.

Federal Circuit Grants En Banc Rehearing in EcoFactor v. Google, Limiting Damages Expert Testimony

The Federal Circuit is reevaluating expert testimony on patent damages, a significant case impacting the patent community and damages awards.
The case could limit damages theories in patent cases, enhancing judicial control over jury-awarded damages.

Drafting for Eligibility: Insights from the Federal Circuit's Contour IP v. GoPro

Federal Circuit reversed summary judgment of patent ineligibility in Contour IP v. GoPro, emphasizing the need for technological improvements in patent claims.

Diamond in the Rough: Can a Composition of Matter Claim Be an Abstract Idea?

The ITC's ruling against US Synthetics' patent represents a significant shift in patent law regarding tangible compositions and abstract ideas.

Supreme Court denies Cert

The Supreme Court dismissed all patent cases in its first conference of the October 2024 term, indicating a possible shift in focus away from patent law.

From Judge Markey's Promise to Rule 36: We Do Not Just Render One-Worded Decisions

The Supreme Court has an opportunity to address the Federal Circuit's use of no-opinion affirmances in patent appeals.

Checking in With Alice Part II: Takeaways and Predictions

The Federal Circuit is limiting patent eligibility for data processing and organizational claims, indicating a harsh landscape for software technologies.

Federal Circuit Grants En Banc Rehearing in EcoFactor v. Google, Limiting Damages Expert Testimony

The Federal Circuit is reevaluating expert testimony on patent damages, a significant case impacting the patent community and damages awards.
The case could limit damages theories in patent cases, enhancing judicial control over jury-awarded damages.

Drafting for Eligibility: Insights from the Federal Circuit's Contour IP v. GoPro

Federal Circuit reversed summary judgment of patent ineligibility in Contour IP v. GoPro, emphasizing the need for technological improvements in patent claims.

Diamond in the Rough: Can a Composition of Matter Claim Be an Abstract Idea?

The ITC's ruling against US Synthetics' patent represents a significant shift in patent law regarding tangible compositions and abstract ideas.

Supreme Court denies Cert

The Supreme Court dismissed all patent cases in its first conference of the October 2024 term, indicating a possible shift in focus away from patent law.
morefederal-circuit
#hatch-waxman-act

Safe Harbor at a Crossroads: Examining Regulatory Development Shield of 271(e)(1) in Edwards v. Meril

The Supreme Court's review of Edwards Lifesciences Corp. v. Meril Life Sciences could redefine the Hatch-Waxman Act's safe harbor provision regarding regulatory and commercial activity scope.

Protecting Pharmaceutical Innovation in Brazil Despite the Lack of a Patent Linkage System

Litigation remains a viable strategy for ensuring market exclusivity despite limitations from the Bolar Exemption.

Teva v. Amneal: Orange Book Listing Requirements Under Scrutiny

The Federal Circuit's ruling may reshape patent listing practices under Hatch-Waxman, influencing generic drug market access.
The case challenges the suitability of listing device patents in the Orange Book regarding patent claims.
The ruling could define how device patents relate to broader patent strategies for pharmaceuticals.

Safe Harbor at a Crossroads: Examining Regulatory Development Shield of 271(e)(1) in Edwards v. Meril

The Supreme Court's review of Edwards Lifesciences Corp. v. Meril Life Sciences could redefine the Hatch-Waxman Act's safe harbor provision regarding regulatory and commercial activity scope.

Protecting Pharmaceutical Innovation in Brazil Despite the Lack of a Patent Linkage System

Litigation remains a viable strategy for ensuring market exclusivity despite limitations from the Bolar Exemption.

Teva v. Amneal: Orange Book Listing Requirements Under Scrutiny

The Federal Circuit's ruling may reshape patent listing practices under Hatch-Waxman, influencing generic drug market access.
The case challenges the suitability of listing device patents in the Orange Book regarding patent claims.
The ruling could define how device patents relate to broader patent strategies for pharmaceuticals.
morehatch-waxman-act
#supreme-court

Return Mail Becomes Latest 101 Petition Denied by SCOTUS

The Supreme Court denied a petition from Return Mail, leaving lower court rulings against its patent claims intact and highlighting issues in Section 101 interpretations.

Supreme Court Asked to Address Constitutionality of Judge Newman Removal

Miller Mendel's petition challenges the Federal Circuit's dismissal of its software patent as an abstract idea, raising critical patent law questions.
The case underlines concerns regarding judicial independence and the authority of Article III judges.

Supreme Court Patent Cases - November 2024

The Supreme Court is reviewing several patent eligibility cases, particularly in the software sector, amidst ongoing legal challenges.
Eight patent-related certiorari petitions are currently pending before the Supreme Court.

Text vs Precedent: Celanese and the Secret Process On-Sale Bar

The Supreme Court may resolve the significant issue of whether sales from secret processes can impact patent protection after the on-sale bar.

Supreme Court's Patent Docket: A Preview of the October 2024 Term

The Supreme Court's Long Conference primarily rejects petitions, with select patent cases expected to receive significant attention this term.

The Enduring Patent Owner/Licensee Standing Distinction

The case examines how multiple entities sharing patent rights affect Article III standing for patent owners, especially after default-related licensing arrangements.

Return Mail Becomes Latest 101 Petition Denied by SCOTUS

The Supreme Court denied a petition from Return Mail, leaving lower court rulings against its patent claims intact and highlighting issues in Section 101 interpretations.

Supreme Court Asked to Address Constitutionality of Judge Newman Removal

Miller Mendel's petition challenges the Federal Circuit's dismissal of its software patent as an abstract idea, raising critical patent law questions.
The case underlines concerns regarding judicial independence and the authority of Article III judges.

Supreme Court Patent Cases - November 2024

The Supreme Court is reviewing several patent eligibility cases, particularly in the software sector, amidst ongoing legal challenges.
Eight patent-related certiorari petitions are currently pending before the Supreme Court.

Text vs Precedent: Celanese and the Secret Process On-Sale Bar

The Supreme Court may resolve the significant issue of whether sales from secret processes can impact patent protection after the on-sale bar.

Supreme Court's Patent Docket: A Preview of the October 2024 Term

The Supreme Court's Long Conference primarily rejects petitions, with select patent cases expected to receive significant attention this term.

The Enduring Patent Owner/Licensee Standing Distinction

The case examines how multiple entities sharing patent rights affect Article III standing for patent owners, especially after default-related licensing arrangements.
moresupreme-court
#innovation

2nd Innovator Diversity Pilots Conference: Advancing Inclusion in Innovation

The conference aims to enhance diversity in innovation through pilot programs and academic discussions.

Only Congressional Patent Reform Can Restore Constitutional Rights

Congressional approval of PERA and PREVAIL acts is essential to restore inventors' property rights and uphold the principles of intellectual property.

A Better Way to RESTORE Injunctive Relief? The Federal Circuit Had the Answer

The debate over patent rights highlights a divide between corporate innovators favoring RESTORE and small innovators supporting RALIA.

The Rise of 'Non-Transitory' Claims: How a Single Word Became Key to Software Patent Eligibility

The percentage of utility patents with 'non-transitory' software claims has increased significantly, reflecting the evolving role of software in patent law.

What Is a Utility Patent? How To Get a Utility Patent (2024) - Shopify

Utility patents protect inventors by ensuring exclusive rights to their inventions for 20 years, promoting innovation and market viability.

3 More Questions For A Patent Podcast Pro (Part I)

Eli Mazour emphasizes the critical role of patents in business success through his podcast and legal practice, enriching the IP community.

2nd Innovator Diversity Pilots Conference: Advancing Inclusion in Innovation

The conference aims to enhance diversity in innovation through pilot programs and academic discussions.

Only Congressional Patent Reform Can Restore Constitutional Rights

Congressional approval of PERA and PREVAIL acts is essential to restore inventors' property rights and uphold the principles of intellectual property.

A Better Way to RESTORE Injunctive Relief? The Federal Circuit Had the Answer

The debate over patent rights highlights a divide between corporate innovators favoring RESTORE and small innovators supporting RALIA.

The Rise of 'Non-Transitory' Claims: How a Single Word Became Key to Software Patent Eligibility

The percentage of utility patents with 'non-transitory' software claims has increased significantly, reflecting the evolving role of software in patent law.

What Is a Utility Patent? How To Get a Utility Patent (2024) - Shopify

Utility patents protect inventors by ensuring exclusive rights to their inventions for 20 years, promoting innovation and market viability.

3 More Questions For A Patent Podcast Pro (Part I)

Eli Mazour emphasizes the critical role of patents in business success through his podcast and legal practice, enriching the IP community.
moreinnovation
#ptab

IDEA Act Moves Forward While Fate of PERA and PREVAIL Seems Uncertain

The Patent Trial and Appeal Board's process is under scrutiny, particularly regarding its impact on small inventors compared to Big Tech.
Key patent bills have been delayed to address concerns about fairness and eligibility in patent law.

Independent Inventor Renews Sotera Stipulation Abuse Allegations at CAFC

The PTAB must consider alleged Sotera violations related to LG's status as a real party-in-interest when invalidating Hafeman's patent claims.

Navigating Unexpected Results: PTAB Decision Outlines Key Requirements for Rule 132 Declarations

PTAB affirmed obviousness rejection of aluminum and magnesium alloy anodizing process claims, despite R132 declaration attempt.

IDEA Act Moves Forward While Fate of PERA and PREVAIL Seems Uncertain

The Patent Trial and Appeal Board's process is under scrutiny, particularly regarding its impact on small inventors compared to Big Tech.
Key patent bills have been delayed to address concerns about fairness and eligibility in patent law.

Independent Inventor Renews Sotera Stipulation Abuse Allegations at CAFC

The PTAB must consider alleged Sotera violations related to LG's status as a real party-in-interest when invalidating Hafeman's patent claims.

Navigating Unexpected Results: PTAB Decision Outlines Key Requirements for Rule 132 Declarations

PTAB affirmed obviousness rejection of aluminum and magnesium alloy anodizing process claims, despite R132 declaration attempt.
moreptab
#artificial-intelligence

The Role of Functional Language in AI Patent Claims

Patenting AI technologies requires clear specification of functions and corresponding structures under § 112(f).

Patterson + Sheridan, LLP is Seeking a Technical Advisor, Patent Agent, or Associate - IPWatchdog.com | Patents & Intellectual Property Law

Patterson + Sheridan, LLP seeks technical professionals for patent law, prioritizing those with backgrounds in AI/ML, Electrical Engineering, and related fields.

The Role of Functional Language in AI Patent Claims

Patenting AI technologies requires clear specification of functions and corresponding structures under § 112(f).

Patterson + Sheridan, LLP is Seeking a Technical Advisor, Patent Agent, or Associate - IPWatchdog.com | Patents & Intellectual Property Law

Patterson + Sheridan, LLP seeks technical professionals for patent law, prioritizing those with backgrounds in AI/ML, Electrical Engineering, and related fields.
moreartificial-intelligence
#intellectual-property

Full Federal Circuit Grants Google's Request for New Hearing in Precedential Ruling on Expert Testimony

CAFC to revisit a decision favoring EcoFactor against Google's appeal on patent infringement and damages.

Patent Owners Beware: Expanded Jurisdiction Risks in Using Third-Party Platforms to Remove Infringing Listings

Patent owners must adapt strategies to navigate new risks from CAFC's ruling on personal jurisdiction in online patent enforcement cases.

Other Barks & Bites for Friday, September 13: Congress Makes Moves on Key IP Bills; Google Deals with Trademark, Patent and Antitrust Cases

Important IP bills are advancing in Congress, including the NO FAKES Act and significant patent legislation.

Patient Rights and Consumer Groups Join EFF In Opposing Two Extreme Patent Bills

The Senate may vote on bills that could increase patent trolling.
PERA aims to reinstate previously banned abstract computer patents.
The PREVAIL Act would limit public challenges to incorrect patents.

Dissecting the USPTO's Update to Eligibility Guidance for AI Inventions

The USPTO's guidance on AI patents aims to clarify eligibility but faces challenges with abstract ideas in patent law.

Protecting Inventor and Corporate Privacy in Previously Recorded Assignment Documents

Proper redaction of sensitive information in patent assignments is crucial to avoid privacy breaches and legal risks.

Full Federal Circuit Grants Google's Request for New Hearing in Precedential Ruling on Expert Testimony

CAFC to revisit a decision favoring EcoFactor against Google's appeal on patent infringement and damages.

Patent Owners Beware: Expanded Jurisdiction Risks in Using Third-Party Platforms to Remove Infringing Listings

Patent owners must adapt strategies to navigate new risks from CAFC's ruling on personal jurisdiction in online patent enforcement cases.

Other Barks & Bites for Friday, September 13: Congress Makes Moves on Key IP Bills; Google Deals with Trademark, Patent and Antitrust Cases

Important IP bills are advancing in Congress, including the NO FAKES Act and significant patent legislation.

Patient Rights and Consumer Groups Join EFF In Opposing Two Extreme Patent Bills

The Senate may vote on bills that could increase patent trolling.
PERA aims to reinstate previously banned abstract computer patents.
The PREVAIL Act would limit public challenges to incorrect patents.

Dissecting the USPTO's Update to Eligibility Guidance for AI Inventions

The USPTO's guidance on AI patents aims to clarify eligibility but faces challenges with abstract ideas in patent law.

Protecting Inventor and Corporate Privacy in Previously Recorded Assignment Documents

Proper redaction of sensitive information in patent assignments is crucial to avoid privacy breaches and legal risks.
moreintellectual-property
#cafc

CAFC Scolds District Court for Straying from 'Party Presentation' Principle

The CAFC reversed the district court's ruling on patent eligibility, noting a fundamental error in its assessment process.

Federal Circuit Says Lanham Act Applies to Crocs' False Claims that 'Croslite' Was Patented

The CAFC ruled that false advertising claims regarding patent claims are actionable under Section 43(a)(1)(B) of the Lanham Act.

ParkerVision is Latest to Petition SCOTUS for Review of CAFC's 'Heavy Reliance' on Rule 36

The CAFC's frequent Rule 36 affirmances raise legal questions regarding the requirement for reasoned opinions under 35 U.S.C. § 144.

CAFC Delivers Win for Patent Owner But Says Claim Construction is OK at Motion to Dismiss Stage

Claim construction is not categorically forbidden during Rule 12(b)(6) motions, allowing for case-specific interpretations.

CAFC Scolds District Court for Straying from 'Party Presentation' Principle

The CAFC reversed the district court's ruling on patent eligibility, noting a fundamental error in its assessment process.

Federal Circuit Says Lanham Act Applies to Crocs' False Claims that 'Croslite' Was Patented

The CAFC ruled that false advertising claims regarding patent claims are actionable under Section 43(a)(1)(B) of the Lanham Act.

ParkerVision is Latest to Petition SCOTUS for Review of CAFC's 'Heavy Reliance' on Rule 36

The CAFC's frequent Rule 36 affirmances raise legal questions regarding the requirement for reasoned opinions under 35 U.S.C. § 144.

CAFC Delivers Win for Patent Owner But Says Claim Construction is OK at Motion to Dismiss Stage

Claim construction is not categorically forbidden during Rule 12(b)(6) motions, allowing for case-specific interpretations.
morecafc
#written-description

If the Barcode Doesn't Fit: Reconsidering 'Bodily Incorporation' in Patent Law

The Nespresso vs. K-Fee IPR cases highlight challenges with patent priority dates and the importance of written descriptions in patent law.

Please Don't Call Me a 'Genus': The High Bar for Section 112 in the Unpredictable Arts as Illustrated by In re Xencor

The threshold for meeting written description and enablement requirements is higher in unpredictable arts than in predictable arts.

If the Barcode Doesn't Fit: Reconsidering 'Bodily Incorporation' in Patent Law

The Nespresso vs. K-Fee IPR cases highlight challenges with patent priority dates and the importance of written descriptions in patent law.

Please Don't Call Me a 'Genus': The High Bar for Section 112 in the Unpredictable Arts as Illustrated by In re Xencor

The threshold for meeting written description and enablement requirements is higher in unpredictable arts than in predictable arts.
morewritten-description

IP & Ski 2025: The Ultimate Intellectual Property Conference Returns to Vail

The IP & Ski Conference combines intellectual property discussions with skiing from January 8-11, 2025, at the Grand Hyatt Vail.

Trade Secrets vs. Patents: Pioneer's Plant Patent Strategy Raises Thorny Issues

The case emphasizes the role of trade secrets in assessing the obviousness of plant patents.

True Respect for Textualism Requires Patent Eligibility Reform

The discussion on patent eligibility highlights the tension between textualism and judicial activism, particularly in how courts interpret patent laws.
#agriculture

Other Barks & Bites for Friday, October 11: DOJ Proposes Breaking Up Google in Ongoing Monopoly Case; Ozempic Maker Settles Patent Infringement Lawsuit; and the CAFC Revives a Patent Infringement Lawsuit Against Salesforce

The U.S. government is addressing key legal and economic issues impacting technology and agriculture sectors, highlighting concerns over monopolistic practices and innovation restraints.

Seeds of Doubt: PTAB Rejects Plant Patent Challenge, Citing Genetic Uncertainty

The PTAB upheld a utility patent for a maize variety developed through simple crossbreeding, emphasizing the importance of genotypic considerations in patent claims.

Other Barks & Bites for Friday, October 11: DOJ Proposes Breaking Up Google in Ongoing Monopoly Case; Ozempic Maker Settles Patent Infringement Lawsuit; and the CAFC Revives a Patent Infringement Lawsuit Against Salesforce

The U.S. government is addressing key legal and economic issues impacting technology and agriculture sectors, highlighting concerns over monopolistic practices and innovation restraints.

Seeds of Doubt: PTAB Rejects Plant Patent Challenge, Citing Genetic Uncertainty

The PTAB upheld a utility patent for a maize variety developed through simple crossbreeding, emphasizing the importance of genotypic considerations in patent claims.
moreagriculture

Pleading Stage Claim Construction

Patent claim construction can occur at the motion-to-dismiss stage, and plural terms may sometimes be interpreted as singular.

NPEs Have No Obligation to Mark Under the Statute-and that Should Extend to an NPE's Settlement Licensees

NPEs can collect patent infringement damages without product marking obligations, but must ensure licensees mark products to avoid limitations on their recovery.

Recent Patent Law Scholarship

Patent law discourse is evolving through diverse academic insights, prompting critical analysis of eligibility, gene patenting, and AI roles in invention.
#patent-infringement

CAFC Says District Court Erred in Dismissing AlexSam's 'Well-Pled' Patent Infringement Claim

The CAFC established a de novo standard of review for trial court determinations on patent infringement complaints.

CAFC Says District Court Erred in Claim Construction Analysis that Held Teleflex Patents Invalid

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reversed a lower court's ruling, reinstating Teleflex's patent claims against Medtronic.

CAFC Says District Court Erred in Dismissing AlexSam's 'Well-Pled' Patent Infringement Claim

The CAFC established a de novo standard of review for trial court determinations on patent infringement complaints.

CAFC Says District Court Erred in Claim Construction Analysis that Held Teleflex Patents Invalid

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reversed a lower court's ruling, reinstating Teleflex's patent claims against Medtronic.
morepatent-infringement
#irreparable-harm

Traditional Principles of Equity Acknowledge that Ongoing Infringement is an Irreparable Harm

The Supreme Court's eBay ruling changed how courts assess irreparable harm in patent infringement cases, impacting injunction eligibility for patent holders.

The Historical Roots of Patent Injunctions: Revisiting Horton v. Maltby (1783)

Ongoing infringement during litigation can establish irreparable harm and warrant injunctive relief according to traditions of equity.

Traditional Principles of Equity Acknowledge that Ongoing Infringement is an Irreparable Harm

The Supreme Court's eBay ruling changed how courts assess irreparable harm in patent infringement cases, impacting injunction eligibility for patent holders.

The Historical Roots of Patent Injunctions: Revisiting Horton v. Maltby (1783)

Ongoing infringement during litigation can establish irreparable harm and warrant injunctive relief according to traditions of equity.
moreirreparable-harm

Biological Deposits in Patent Applications: Why, When and Where

The Budapest Treaty simplifies the patent application process for biological inventions by requiring one deposit to fulfill multiple jurisdictional obligations.

A Proposal for Improving the PREVAIL Act

The PREVAIL Act aims to improve patent owner protections by reforming AIA review processes to foster fairness and transparency.

Other Barks & Bites for Friday, September 20: Biden Administration Announces $3 Billion Advanced Battery Investment; Fifth Circuit Affirms Fair Use Ruling on Dog Art Kits; and California Passes State Bills on Digital Replica Rights

Federal Circuit's ruling emphasizes adherence to statutory presumption of patent validity.
California joins several states in protecting against unauthorized digital replicas of individuals.

Eligibility, IPRs, and Diversity: The Faces of 2024 Patent Reform

Three major patent bills are currently under negotiation in the Senate Judiciary Committee, facing opposition from several members and constituents.

Precluded, Not Repeated: WARF & Apple Continue to Shape our Understanding of Issue Preclusion in Patent Law

WARF's waiver of the doctrine-of-equivalents in WARF I precludes its application in subsequent litigation on newer technology versions. The decision emphasizes strategic litigation importance.

Celanese v. ITC: How the On-Sale Bar Can Turn Sweet Sales into Spoiled Patents

Celanese's attempt to assert patent rights was undermined by previous undisclosed sales triggering the on-sale bar, reaffirming AIA's impact on patent law.

Managing tipping payments is an administrative problem, not a technological problem

The Federal Circuit ruled that VidAngel's patent application for eliciting media content tips is ineligible, underscoring strict patent eligibility standards.
[ Load more ]