"A veteran scans every room for exits, catalogs potential threats, and maintains tactical awareness even at his daughter's birthday party. A police officer can't turn off the hypervigilance when she gets home, and treats her husband's questions like interrogations. A woman who survived years of emotional abuse reads micro-expressions obsessively, predicting her new partner's mood shifts before they happen. Different lives. Same pattern. They tell me some version of: "I can't turn it off.""
"And I think: Why would they? They've achieved mastery. Why Trauma Survivors Can't Turn It Off This is what I've encountered repeatedly in 20 years of clinical practice. My clients with the most sophisticated trauma responses aren't the ones stuck in primitive fear. They've developed elaborate, coherent, systematic understandings of threat and safety. They've achieved what looks like wisdom -just wisdom about the wrong world."
"In January 2023, I woke before dawn to a fire alarm. I discovered fire in the back of my house, went for the hose, and found the fire was much bigger outside than I'd realized. No phone, no neighbors, almost no clothes. I made the choice to keep fighting it rather than watch everything burn. I fought that fire until the firefighters arrived and could get their hoses on it. There are good reasons they wear all that equipment, and spray the water"
Trauma survivors often develop highly organized cognitive and bodily strategies oriented toward detecting and managing threat rather than primitive fear responses. These strategies can resemble expertise: tactical scanning, hypervigilant interpretation of social cues, and predictive threat models that persist across contexts. Neural architecture supports a hierarchy from brainstem reflexes up to prefrontal integration, analogous to Plato's divided line. Recurrent traumatic activation can wire pathways around destructive, fire-like principles or around life-giving, sun-like principles. Acute survival choices and repeated defensive practices consolidate these neural patterns, making them durable, context-generalized, and difficult to switch off without intentional intervention.
Read at Psychology Today
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]