Judith Thurman's depiction of Simone Weil's childhood and character perpetuates misleading narratives about her background, familial wealth, and relationship with Judaism.
The portrayal of Simone’s childhood suggests a 'privileged' upbringing, yet my grandparents were not wealthy, and her experiences were far from luxurious.
Thurman’s commentary on Simone’s identity reflects broader misconceptions, reducing complex relationships with Judaism to mere projections of others' feelings and biases.
Simone’s sardonic letter to the Vichy authorities critiques the absurdity of racial laws; it’s a philosophical riddle, not a denial of her identity.
[
Collection
]
[
|
...
]