A federal civil jury found San Jose police officer Edward Carboni not liable for excessive force in the 2019 shooting of Francis Calonge, who was experiencing a psychiatric crisis. Despite Calonge carrying a replica gun and disregarding police orders, jurors determined Carboni acted reasonably to protect public safety. City Attorney Nora Frimann acknowledged the need for better mental health services, reflecting on the tragedy of the loss for Calonge's family. The necessary legal protections for officers involved in such cases were reaffirmed following previous court decisions on qualified immunity.
The jury's decision underscores the belief that Officer Edward Carboni acted within his rights during the tragic encounter with Francis Calonge, considering the circumstances.
City Attorney Nora Frimann emphasized the necessity for improved mental health services, acknowledging the tragic loss experienced by Calonge's family during the incident.
The court had previously determined that Officer Carboni was protected by qualified immunity, reinforcing the challenges faced in cases involving law enforcement actions.
The incident highlights the delicate balance law enforcement must maintain when responding to situations involving individuals experiencing mental health crises.
Collection
[
|
...
]