Amazon and A24 Made a Buzzy New Show With a Rising Star. It's Not What I Was Expecting.
Briefly

Overcompensating, a new comedy-drama on Amazon Prime Video created by Benito Skinner, explores the life of Benny, a closeted gay college freshman. The show's timing is ambiguous, blending elements from various years and feeling disconnected from both Gen Z and millennials. Its themes address Benny's internal struggles and interactions, but it fails to deliver a clear identity—a mix of humor and seriousness that results in an experience lacking depth and clarity, leaving viewers questioning its intent and resonance.
The show is both too gay for straight audiences and too straight for gay audiences, failing to resonate with either demographic.
Ultimately, Overcompensating is a project that feels confused and lacks both humor and dramatic depth, leaving viewers with an unclear experience.
Read at Slate Magazine
[
|
]