Johnny's Reef, a City Island staple since 1974, is known for its chill vibes and generous portions of seafood. The cafeteria offers a massive menu featuring fried options like shrimp and scallops, as well as steam-cooked seafood with sides. While fried fish is the main attraction, higher-end offerings include lobster tail and oysters at reasonable prices. Reviews praise the crab legs' exquisite seasoning and the crispy fries, highlighting the restaurant's popularity and ability to deliver quality meals without high costs.
Fried fish is obviously the star at Johnny's Reef, with offerings ranging from casual diner favorites like fried shrimp to higher-end options like lobster tail and oysters.
In 2023, a patron posted a picture of their massive shrimp and soft-shell crab spread on Reddit, leading to surprise that the total was just $29.
Johnny's Reef offers a massive menu of fried seafood, including shellfish classics and numerous sides, providing diverse options for diners seeking high-quality meals.
The restaurant remains perennially popular during its open season, which spans from early spring until late fall, showcasing its status as a City Island staple.
Collection
[
|
...
]