"Ye's core talent was always his ability to dig up grand, poignant samples and make them feel like his private chorus, earthbending them around his presence until he seemed in control of the whole universe."
"There's a tender ache in his voice on the title track as he calmly describes his system running amok. 'I wanna beat somebody up/Like a bully,' he states, his voice curling as he arrives at a meaningful conclusion."
"'Circles' is so laughably undercooked that it almost comes out the other end as a clever meta-statement on his own behavior patterns."
The album suffers from a lack of depth, with most songs being under two minutes and predictable in content. Tracks like 'Damn' repeat verses without variation, while 'Circles' feels underdeveloped. Ye's signature sampling ability is present, but his vocal delivery lacks sharpness. The album occasionally surprises with moments of vulnerability, particularly in the title track and 'Mama's Favorite,' where Ye reveals insecurities beneath his confident persona. Overall, the project feels empty and fails to showcase Ye's full artistic potential.
Read at Pitchfork
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]