The new ethics code introduced by the Supreme Court in November 2023 faced criticism for being based on an 'honor system' without an enforcement mechanism, a concern raised by the liberal justices.
Justice Neil Gorsuch expressed fears that implementing an enforcement mechanism could undermine the integrity of the Supreme Court, voicing his concerns in a detailed memo that questioned the need for strict measures.
Responses among other justices revealed a dismissive attitude toward critiques of the court's ethics, with Justices Thomas and Alito characterizing critics as politically motivated, rather than objectively examining the need for higher ethical standards.
Chief Justice John Roberts attempted to adapt the court's ethics guidelines under pressure from media scrutiny around Justice Thomas, but still prioritized confidentiality among the justices, hampering transparency.
Collection
[
|
...
]