Judge blocks California city from enforcing 1895 disorderly conduct law, rules it likely violates First Amendment

A federal judge ruled that a 1895 San Diego law banning offensive conduct is likely unconstitutional, backing the First Amendment rights of street artist William Dorsett.

The law's vagueness and overbreadth drew criticism, with a judge highlighting its similarities to a Texas ordinance previously ruled unconstitutional by the U.S. Supreme Court.

San Diego City Attorney's office initially supported Dorsett’s First Amendment claim but later reversed stance, arguing that words could obstruct law enforcement duties.

The ruling suggests a growing recognition of artistic expression and civil protest rights, particularly in public spaces where law enforcement and citizen interactions occur.

Read at www.mercurynews.com