Blue Jays: Addison Barger needs to play every day to realize his full potential

"Barger will undoubtedly be eased back into game action, the Blue Jays should prioritize playing him every day once he's back up to speed so he reaches his full potential. Barger is too young and talented to be relegated to a platoon role this early in his career. The Blue Jays could afford to deploy him primarily against right-handed pitchers last season because of all the depth on their roster. They need Barger to be an everyday player in 2026, and that will involve coaching him through some growing pains."

"The 26-year-old recorded a .607 OPS against left-handed pitching in 2025, compared to a .788 mark against right-handers. Just 119 of his 687 career at-bats have come against southpaws to this point-far too small a sample size to draw any meaningful conclusions. He also hit the first pinch-hit grand slam in World Series history off a lefty pitcher."

"The fact of the matter is that Barger has exponentially more offensive upside than the likes of Myles Straw or Davis Schneider, regardless of who is pitching. The ball comes off his bat differently than it does for those two. The Blue Jays need all the thump they can get; they're doing themselves and Barger a disservice by platooning him."

"This isn't to say Barger should have an unlimited leash. He may eventually prove that he genuinely can't handle lefties over a larger sample size. The Blue Jays will have to re-evaluate if that ends up being the case, but there isn't enough data right now. Jesús Sánchez is proof that some lefty bats never figure out how to hit same-handed pitchers, as he's hit just .182 with 128 strikeouts in 369 career at-bats against southpaws."

Barger has been out since April 5 with a serious ankle sprain, and the Blue Jays’ offense has lacked his power production. Once he is ready, he should be played every day to reach his full potential rather than being used in a platoon role. Barger is young and talented, and the team needs him as an everyday bat in 2026, even if coaching requires managing early growing pains. In 2025, he posted a .607 OPS versus left-handed pitching and a .788 OPS versus right-handers, but only 119 of 687 career at-bats have come against southpaws. He also hit a pinch-hit grand slam in World Series history off a left-handed pitcher, showing meaningful upside. The team should not overreact to limited data and should re-evaluate only if larger samples later show he cannot handle lefties.

Read at BlueJaysNation