While mainstream college basketball coverage centers on this season's powerhouses like Arizona and Michigan, seasoned bettors know that brand recognition doesn't always equal ATS value. In fact, the market's "Blue Blood" bias often creates more opportunities with smaller programs. As we examine the top NCAAB ATS performers this season, the leaderboard includes several unexpected teams consistently outperforming oddsmakers' expectations. Best 2025-26 NCAAB ATS Records
Valparaiso suffered defeat by a final score of 76-57 in their last game against UIC. Leading the way on offense for the Beacons was Allia von Schlegell, who ended the game with nine points. Kamryn Winch posted nine points and 12 rebounds. Led by BreAunna Ward with 22 points, eight rebounds, four steals and three blocks last time out, Evansville lost 78-75 versus Indiana State.