The Turkey Tom (#4 on the menu) has a devoted following, but we actually think it's one of the blandest, most forgettable options on the menu. It landed near the bottom of our ranking of popular Jimmy John's sandwiches published in 2023 and also made our list of Jimmy John's sandwiches you should think twice about ordering. It comes with a few slices of turkey, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise. "It's a sandwich that you could very easily make at home," states our writer.
Oh, Jimmy John's. It was the place that you ordered from at 3 a.m. in college when the idea of microwaving a plastic cup of mac and cheese sounded downright repulsive. You may know it as the best sandwich joint to eat from if you prefer a really, really soggy sandwich, or perhaps you're more familiar with its history of union-busting and preventing its workers from organizing for fairer working standards. Despite those issues, it's a sub chain that has its fair share of followers.
Tasting Table has ranked the most popular of Jimmy John's sandwiches already, since it's a sandwich shop first and foremost, but the cookies are such a shining star that even the notoriously fraught internet is alight with glowing reviews of them.