#film-criticism

[ follow ]
#academy-awards
fromThe Independent
17 hours ago
Independent films

The 10 worst Oscar Best Picture winners of all time

The Academy's Best Picture choices often reflect herd mentality from earlier awards shows, resulting in questionable winners that don't deserve the honor.
fromwww.theguardian.com
2 days ago
Film

Reader Q&A: Catherine Shoard answers your questions on the 2026 Oscars

Guardian film critics discuss their predictions and opinions on 98th Academy Awards contenders, inviting reader questions and debate about nominees and categories.
Independent films
fromThe Independent
17 hours ago

The 10 worst Oscar Best Picture winners of all time

The Academy's Best Picture choices often reflect herd mentality from earlier awards shows, resulting in questionable winners that don't deserve the honor.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
2 days ago

Reader Q&A: Catherine Shoard answers your questions on the 2026 Oscars

Guardian film critics discuss their predictions and opinions on 98th Academy Awards contenders, inviting reader questions and debate about nominees and categories.
Film
fromIndieWire
10 hours ago

Anonymous Ballot: Director Favors 'Sinners' and Ryan Coogler as the Filmmaker of the Future

An Oscar voter discusses their top directorial choices, praising Ryan Coogler's 'Sinners' alongside standout films for innovative editing, structural clarity, and intricate character dynamics.
fromThe Nation
22 hours ago

Who Will Win Big at the Oscars?

From its opening scene-a shakedown of Armando Solimões (Wagner Moura) by local authorities at a rural gas station-Kleber Mendonça Filho immerses viewers in a world of casual corruption and clandestine violence endemic to authoritarian rule.
Film
Berlin food
fromwww.theguardian.com
3 days ago

The Tasters review wartime historical drama about Hitler's Wolf's Lair food samplers

A film adaptation depicts young women forced to taste Hitler's food, though historians lack evidence supporting this historical claim.
#romantic-comedy
Film
fromConsequence
3 days ago

Quentin Tarantino Says Rosanna Arquette Has "Lack of Class, No Less Honor" After She Criticized His N-Word Use

Tarantino accused Arquette of disrespecting him and seeking publicity by criticizing his use of the N-word in his films, claiming she benefited from working with him.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
4 days ago

Learning You review autism road trip drama is hard to bear

A film depicting a father's relationship with his autistic son struggling with severe support needs uses religious messaging and sentimentality to explore acceptance, though execution is criticized as heavy-handed and overly sentimental.
Independent films
fromwww.nytimes.com
4 days ago

14 of the Worst Movie Casting Choices

Several acclaimed actors deliver mismatched or unconvincing performances in major films, struggling with character demands, accents, age gaps, or overwhelming production spectacle.
Film
fromSlate Magazine
4 days ago

She Went From Reality Star to Best Actress Front-Runner. She Deserves It All.

The Bride! fails as a film by attempting too many conflicting genres, tones, and stylistic approaches simultaneously, undermining its ambitions as both camp entertainment and serious feminist commentary.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
4 days ago

Scarlet review Mamoru Hosoda turns Hamlet into tale of prowling knights and deep nothingness'

Mamoru Hosoda's anime adaptation of Hamlet, Scarlet, features stunning visuals but suffers from incoherent storytelling, arbitrary world-building, and heavy-handed philosophical messaging that undermines its narrative impact.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
4 days ago

Why Train Dreams should win the best picture Oscar

Train Dreams offers a meditative, character-driven narrative that contrasts with contemporary cinema's frenetic pacing and empty provocations, presenting a more substantive storytelling approach reminiscent of classic filmmaking.
#quentin-tarantino
Film
fromVulture
1 week ago

The Peaky Blinders Movie Indulges the Show's Worst Tendencies

Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man opens with a real WWII bombing in Birmingham and struggles between serious historical stakes and glorifying its protagonist's violence.
Film
fromThe Atlantic
1 week ago

'The Bride!' Is a Failed Experiment

Maggie Gyllenhaal's The Bride! attempts an ambitious reimagining of Bride of Frankenstein but loses its social commentary beneath excessive stylistic choices and tonal inconsistency.
fromVulture
1 week ago

17 Movies With Exclamation-Point Titles, Ranked!

During a junket interview with OutNow, Gyllenhaal explained that the punctuation mark was included to represent the "whole lot of energy" that comes out when the historically muted Bride of Frankenstein is finally allowed to speak. That's all well and good, but to viewers the titular exclamation point is less of a metaphor and more of a golden arrow saying, "This movie is going to be crazy."
Film
#frankenstein-adaptation
fromEsquire
1 week ago
Film

Maggie Gyllenhaal's 'The Bride!' Is (Really) Polarizing Audiences

Maggie Gyllenhaal's The Bride! reinterprets the Frankenstein story from a feminist perspective, reimagining the characters as a 1930s Chicago crime couple, but receives sharply divided critical reviews.
fromThe New Yorker
1 week ago
Film

"The Bride!" Is All Exclamations but No Explanations

Maggie Gyllenhaal's Frankenstein adaptation explores systemic gender oppression through a woman pushed to her breaking point, but fails to fully develop its thematic premise and moral implications.
Film
fromThe New Yorker
1 week ago

"The Bride!" Is All Exclamations but No Explanations

Maggie Gyllenhaal's Frankenstein adaptation explores systemic gender oppression through a woman pushed to her breaking point, but fails to fully develop its thematic premise and moral implications.
Film
fromIndieWire
1 week ago

'The Bride!' Review: Maggie Gyllenhaal Graverobs Mary Shelley for a Wokified, 'Joker'-fied Folie-a-Deux Zonked on Its Own Rage

Maggie Gyllenhaal's 'The Bride!' attempts feminist reinterpretation of Frankenstein's monster but delivers a one-dimensional rage narrative that feels outdated despite contemporary feminist themes.
Film
fromVulture
2 weeks ago

Protesters at Scream 7 Premiere Call for 'Free Palestine'

Scream 7 faces multiple controversies including boycotts over actress firing, Letterboxd review locks, and corporate partnerships, yet tracking suggests strong opening weekend performance.
fromThe New Yorker
2 weeks ago

Critics at Large Live: "Wuthering Heights" and Its Afterlives

James Lorimer, writing in the North British Review, promised that the novel would 'never be generally read.' Nearly two centuries later, it's regarded as one of the great works of English literature.
Film
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
2 weeks ago

In the Blink of an Eye review Pixar director's long-delayed sci-fi epic falls flat

Andrew Stanton's sci-fi epic spanning 45,000 years to future planets fails to deliver emotional depth or narrative coherence, resulting in an awkwardly constructed and unintentionally comedic film.
fromSlate Magazine
2 weeks ago

What If the Gang from Derry Girls Grew Up to Solve Mysteries?

In the Netflix series, three longtime Belfast friends must revisit their childhood trauma to unravel the mystery of a fourth friend's disappearance- raucous Northern Irish hijinks ensue.
Podcast
fromIndependent
3 weeks ago

Tanya Sweeney: The 'Wuthering Heights' backlash is not about the movie - but the woman who made it

When a woman directs boldly, it's trashy. When a man does, it's visionary
Film
fromWorld of Reel
6 years ago

Warner Bros. Paid 2,000+ Social Media Influencers to "Post Nice Things" About 'Wuthering Heights' - World of Reel

Remember when "Wuthering Heights" first screened and all those glowing early reactions flooded social media-with even one "critic" calling it a "God-tier classic"? It turns out that was a carefully calibrated mirage concocted by Warner Bros. A report claims that "Wuthering Heights" had "one of the biggest global marketing juggernauts the world has ever seen." Hyperbole? Maybe. But what do you make of the claim that "almost 2,000 social media influencers were paid by Warners to post nice things about the film"?
Film
Film
fromDefector
3 weeks ago

Where Is Cinema?: An Interview With A.S. Hamrah | Defector

Rigorous film criticism remains vital, chronicling cinema's degradation while defending independent and underground filmmaking against industrial consolidation and technological homogenization.
Film
fromThe New Yorker
4 weeks ago

Richard Brody Presents the 2026 Brody Awards

The New Yorker Radio Hour features Richard Brody, David Remnick, and Alexandra Schwartz reviewing the year's best, overlooked, and overpraised films; episodes drop Tuesdays.
Film
fromSan Francisco Bay Times
4 weeks ago

A Conversation With Jan Wahl - San Francisco Bay Times

Jan Wahl grew up in classic Hollywood, pursued a career engaging with film figures, and worries modern cinema favors youth-oriented, fast-cut, fragmented narratives over thoughtful storytelling.
Film
fromInverse
1 month ago

31 Years Later, David Fincher's Darkest Thriller Just Got A Huge Upgrade

David Fincher balances artistic integrity and commercial work, with Seven establishing his career and prompting renewed interest after a 4K Blu-ray refresh.
Film
fromInverse
1 month ago

'Wuthering Heights' Is Not The Sicko Gothic Fantasy We Were Promised

Emerald Fennell's Wuthering Heights impresses visually but fails to deliver the provocative, scandalous reinterpretation many expected of the classic novel.
Film
fromFuturism
1 month ago

The Reviews are in on Darren Aronofsky's AI-Generated Show, and May We Just Say: "Yikes"

Darren Aronofsky released an almost entirely AI-generated Revolutionary War video series whose poor AI visuals, anachronisms, and montage style have prompted widespread condemnation.
#horror
Film
fromThe Washington Post
1 month ago

Review | A famous director, a talented cast and a 'Dracula' that is endlessly bad

Hollywood increasingly remakes Gothic horror classics as tentpole films, with major directors recycling old stories into often disappointing, confounding new versions.
fromThe Nation
1 month ago

Is it Too Late to Save Hollywood?

"The thing I don't understand is how you lose money running a laundromat," Hamrah writes, "especially if you own the building."
Film
#melania-trump
fromSlate Magazine
1 month ago

In Hamnet, the Rest Is Not Silence.

Shuffling under the mortal coil this week (aka hosting the Gabfest), it's our OG players Steve, Dana, and Julia. Like a morose Danish prince contemplating a human skull, they gaze upon the Oscar nominated , based on the novel by Maggie O'Farrell inspired by William Shakespeare's life. Directed by Chloé Zhao and starring Jessie Buckley and Paul Mescal, Hamnet has brought some critics to tears and left others cold. Our hosts share where they landed.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
1 month ago

The Gallerist review Natalie Portman flounders in tiring art world caper

There's a mildly amusing on-paper joke at the centre of manic art world comedy The Gallerist: what if someone was accidentally impaled on an exhibit but rather than report it, the corpse became part of the artwork? Sure, poking fun at the absurdity of modern art might seem a little dated and definitely a little too easy but maybe with a packed cast including Oscar winners Natalie Portman, Catherine Zeta-Jones and Da'Vine Joy Randolph, there could be a fun, fast-paced caper here?
Film
Film
fromInsideHook
1 month ago

In Defense of Movie Sex Scenes

Onscreen sex scenes can be narratively essential but are often gratuitous, harmful, or disruptive when objectifying participants, reinforcing stereotypes, or damaging a film's flow.
#journalism-funding
US politics
fromwww.independent.co.uk
1 month ago

One Battle After Another is a ferocious masterpiece review

Donations fund independent, paywall-free journalism that supports on-the-ground reporting; Paul Thomas Anderson's film depicts living resistance against white supremacy.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
1 month ago

It's already yesterday again: the 20 best time-loop movies ranked!

Time-loop films recycle the reset premise while varying stakes and constraints, with urgency or exposition determining whether repetition enhances drama or undermines suspense.
Film
fromKqed
1 month ago

New Chris Pratt Movie 'Mercy' Is a Total Trial

Mercy squanders a tense countdown and AI legal premise, producing a tedious, screen-bound thriller that underutilizes Chris Pratt and Rebecca Ferguson.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
1 month ago

Aryan Papers review Holocaust-themed thriller means well but turns out to be a shockingly poor effort

Danny Patrick's low-budget WWII drama Aryan Papers is poorly executed, featuring a weak script, bad acting, confused editing, and obvious production flaws.
fromRoger Ebert
1 month ago

Remote-Droppers and Jeff Bridges: Nick Digilio on His Book About 40 Years Reviewing Movies | Interviews | Roger Ebert

Nick Digilio has been a movie critic for 40 years, for many of those years on WGN radio, now with a popular podcast and hosting screenings in Chicago. And I've been talking to him about movies for 25 of those years. I still remember our first conversation, which included a discussion of "Donnie Darko" and the mid-century Hollywood director Douglas Sirk. He usually interviews me, but in honor of his new book, 40 Years, 40 Films, we switched, and I got to interview him.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
1 month ago

The crying game: what Hamnet's grief-porn debate says about women, cinema and enormous hawks

Grief-porn, in relation to cinema, would suggest that the film in question is emotionally manipulative, formulaic; grief-art would suggest the film unleashes feelings both universal and true. It's curiously circular. In a film about grief, the valorised quality is depth of feeling; it stands or falls by how profoundly the hero(ine) experiences emotion, and the audience proves its acuity, buys itself into the imaginative contract, by its ability to mirror that profundity.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
1 month ago

Rental Family review Brendan Fraser seeks meaning in pointless Japanese role-play drama

Fraser plays Phillip, a hapless unemployed actor from the US who a few years previously came to Tokyo to do a goofy TV ad for toothpaste and, having no friends or family back home, simply stayed on. He lucks into a weird new source of income: working for a rental family, based on firms in Japan which really do offer bespoke therapeutic role-play services, such as errant spouses, deceased
Film
Film
fromIndieWire
2 months ago

Critics, Filmmakers, and Why the Future of Movies Belongs to the People Who Give a Sh*t About Them

At the New York Film Critics Circle awards dinner, a lengthy speech about critics' relationship with filmmakers prompted playful roasts from presenters.
#journalism
Film
fromRoger Ebert
2 months ago

Happy New Year 2026 from Chaz Ebert and Everyone at RogerEbert.com | Chaz's Journal | Roger Ebert

Roger Ebert's website continued in 2025 through a dedicated editorial and corporate team honoring his legacy and celebrating the Siskel & Ebert film-criticism tradition.
Film
fromBusiness Insider
2 months ago

Stop calling everything a flop: It was a good year for the movies.

2025 produced many excellent films despite weak box-office totals, showing box-office revenue is an unreliable measure of cinematic quality.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
2 months ago

Move fast, break stuff': how tech bros became Hollywood's go-to baddie in 2025

2025 saw obnoxious tech-bro culture dominate public life and Hollywood, producing clichéd villain archetypes and oversaturated satirical portrayals.
Film
fromSlate Magazine
2 months ago

Two of Our Most Lovable Stars Made a Delightful Movie This Year. Then It Disappeared.

Personal memories of encountering Rob Reiner's films reveal their deep role in shaping individual and collective experiences of American cinema.
fromInverse
2 months ago

45 Years Ago, A Trippy Sci-Fi Movie Changed The Body Horror Genre

Russell had already cemented his audacious sensibilities with Tommy and The Devils, but this sci-fi horror, released 45 years ago today, pushes the limits of sensory overload. Renowned screenwriter and novelist Paddy Chayefsky (best known for Network and The Hospital) wrote a powerhouse script based on his surreal 1978 novel, itself inspired by neuroscientist John Cunningham Lilly's research on sensory deprivation tanks and psychedelics.
Film
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
2 months ago

It's turkey time! The 12 worst films of 2025

Recent films display self-indulgence, merchandising-driven remakes, listless musicals, overwrought storytelling, and lazy knockoff filmmaking.
Film
fromIndieWire
2 months ago

'Anaconda' Review: Paul Rudd and Jack Black Star in Lazy Meta-Sequel That Squeezes All the Fun Out of Self-Reflexive Premise

Tom Gormican's new Anaconda is a sweet-natured but slipshod comedy meta-sequel that fails to contextualize the 1997 original and feels ambivalent and confused.
Film
fromKotaku
2 months ago

These 12 Movies Have A Higher RT Score Than Avatar 3 - Kotaku

Avatar: Fire and Ash has a 68% Rotten Tomatoes critics score, lower than earlier Avatar films and trailing some recent releases like the new SpongeBob movie.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
3 months ago

Ella McCay review James L Brooks returns with a sorry mess of a movie

Ella McCay is a nostalgically styled mid-budget comedy-drama that is well cast but undermined by incoherent characters and a confounding, illogical plot.
#netflix-christmas-movies
#five-nights-at-freddys
fromJezebel
3 months ago

Kristen Stewart's The Chronology Of Water Liquifies Trauma into a Slurry

A biopic that skips along the surface of its subject, deriving cliched psychological insight from its traumatized source, The Chronology Of Water sees Kristen Stewart liquify Lidia Yuknavitch's memoir into a expressionistic slurry. In her feature debut as writer-director, Stewart takes explicit pains to explicitly render Yuknavitch's pain on screen, drenching the swimmer-turned-writer's life-spanning childhood abuse, young-adult hedonism, and professional success-in over-styled and overindulgent imagery.
Film
Film
fromThe New Yorker
3 months ago

The Best Films of 2025

2022 produced outstanding films across international, festival, and studio releases, offering emotionally powerful moments despite escalating geopolitical crises and societal turmoil.
fromVulture
3 months ago

What Did Paul Dano Do to Quentin Tarantino?

Tarantino listed his 20 favorite movies on The Bret Easton Ellis Podcast, and when discussing his no. 5 pick, Paul Thomas Anderson's There Will Be Blood, he had a shocking view of Paul Dano's performance as twins Paul & Eli Sunday. " There Will Be Blood would stand a good chance at being no. 1 or 2 if it didn't have a big, giant flaw in it ... and the flaw is Paul Dano," Tarantino shared as he compared Dano's performance to Daniel Day-Lewis.
Film
fromVulture
3 months ago

Eternity's Vision of the Afterlife Will Drive You Crazy

Eternity doesn't rank among them, though director David Freyne and his co-writer Pat Cunnane deserve some credit for setting their sights so high. They have built an entire vision of the afterlife to serve as the setting for their otherwise modest romantic comedy. Okay, some credit ... and maybe also some blame. The beyond that they've conjured up is so ridiculously specific that we can't help but start poking holes in it.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
3 months ago

Sirat review rave in the desert leads to exasperating quest in the sands of Morocco

Oliver Laxe leads his audience into a wilderness of non-meaning in this strange and unrewardingly oppressive film that was the joint jury prize winner at Cannes this year and the recipient of all sorts of critical superlatives. For me, Sirat is the most overpraised movie of the year exasperating and bizarre in ways that become less and less interesting and more and more ridiculous as the film wears on.
Film
#siskel--ebert
Film
fromRoger Ebert
3 months ago

My Dinner with Gene & Roger | Roger Ebert | Roger Ebert

Influential television critics transformed My Dinner with Andre from near-obscurity into a nationwide box-office success.
fromThe New Yorker
3 months ago

Our Film Critic on Where "Wicked" Went Wrong

[ Big sigh.] Well, reactions have been divided already. This may speak more to my reaction than anyone else's but I think the feeling will be Didn't we just do this a year ago? And with this movie opening now, right as the annual scourge that we call awards season is getting under way, I'm sure people will be talking about performances.
Film
fromRoger Ebert
3 months ago

Making Dreams Feel Real: A Memory of Siskel & Ebert | Roger Ebert | Roger Ebert

Between the ages of 3 and 5, I fell in love with the movies after seeing my very first one, learned how to read and write, and discovered there was actually a job out there that combined all of those things into one: A film critic. From that point on, I knew what I wanted to do with my life. And while my peers may have yearned to be doctors or firemen or the like, I wanted to watch movies and write about them,
Film
fromSan Francisco Bay Times
3 months ago

Missing Judgement at Nuremberg - San Francisco Bay Times

A psychiatrist is tasked with analyzing Hermann Göring and other Nazis as they fight for their lives during the Nuremberg trials. These men orchestrated the deaths of over 6 million Jews, homosexuals, Gypsies, and political opponents. Did they feel remorse, guilt, or nothing at all? It is such a great concept for a story and plot, but, in Nuremberg, they really blew it.
Film
Film
fromThe New Yorker
3 months ago

What's the Best Movie About the Subway?

Amanda Dobbins and Sean Fennessey host "The Big Picture," blending sharp film criticism, playful banter, and live competitive movie-draft events.
fromVulture
3 months ago

Now You See Reviews for Now You See Me: Now You Don't

In the Now You See Me movies, the so-called explanations for the big tricks are even more ridiculous than the tricks themselves; they're not built on the characters' skill or determination or cleverness, but on narrative convenience and screenwriter contrivance. These films are anti-magic: They quash the wonder of both a perfectly executed trick and its oh wow reveal. (This also makes them bad heist movies, by the way.)
Film
fromInverse
3 months ago

'Keeper' Is Another Oz Perkins Snooze

Scored to the upbeat romantic sounds of Mickey & Sylvia's "Love is Strange, a brief collage from a ghostly POV hops and skips through time, as various women across the decades and centuries become enamored with some ghostly, unseen figure, but each romance soon curdles. Awkward silences abound, speaking volumes even in musical montage. These things happen, after all. Boy meets girl. They fall in love. They drift apart. It ends in bloodshed.
Film
fromIndieWire
3 months ago

'Anaconda' Is a Better Than 'Vertigo': Why Hollywood Should Leave the Classics Alone and Focus on Remaking Bad Movies Instead of Good Ones

The first is that they all should have spawned gratuitously sleazed out direct-to-video sequels that recast Amy Adams in the lead role and aired on Cinemax every other night for the entirety of my high school years (shout out to Roger Kumble, the James Mangold of Adrian Lynes). The second - and perhaps more broadly relevant - aspect that binds those movies together is that Hollywood is currently in the process of remaking each and every one of them.
Film
Film
fromVulture
3 months ago

The Dumbest Major Movie Franchise Strikes Again

Magic in cinema fails when films hide artifice yet portray magicians as implausible superpowered figures, causing tedium and frustration instead of wonder.
Film
fromwww.theguardian.com
3 months ago

I'm still processing how awful it was': your zero-star screen disasters

Playmobil: The Movie is garish and loud; Lancelot Link is exploitative and vile; Waterworld proves unintentionally hilarious.
#television-history
Arts
fromwww.npr.org
4 months ago

'Sentimental Value' is a family drama that lets everyone off the hook too easily

Sentimental Value explores fraught parent-child relationships and strong acting but reads as self-consciously mature and less lively than Trier's earlier, richer films.
[ Load more ]