Deja vu: Diaz deal with Mets not paid off until '42
NEW YORK -- Edwin Díaz's $102 million, five-year contract with the New York Mets includes $26.5 million in deferred payments that he won't completely receive until 2042 and also has a club option for 2028 that could make the deal worth $118.25 million over six seasons.Díaz's deal, announced Wednesday, set a record for dollars guaranteed to a relief pitcher.
Pirates Designate Canaan Smith-Njigba For Assignment
The Pirates have designated outfielder Canaan Smith-Njigba for assignment to make room for Aroldis Chapman on the roster.
Despite limited playing time in the MLB, Smith-Njigba has had success in the minor leagues, with a combined .273/.366/.439 output at the top level. [ more ]
The market for pure relievers has been slow this winter, with only four full-time relievers signing multi-year contracts so far.
Josh Hader is considered the top available reliever in free agency, followed by dominant right-handed arms.
Aroldis Chapman and Andrew Miller are two top left-handed relief options, with Chapman having a highly recognized career and Miller known for his versatility. [ more ]
La seleccion cubana en el Clasico Mundial de Beisbol se define por los jugadores que estan y los que no
Cuando Cuba salio al campo el miercoles en Taiwan para inaugurar la edicion mas reciente del Clasico Mundial de Beisbol, el pais hizo historia al contar con algunos nombres notables de las Grandes Ligas.Luis Robert Jr., el destacado jugador de los Medias Blancas, patrullo el jardin, mientras que su companero de equipo en Chicago Yoan Moncada estuvo en el diamante.
The end of summer vacation is always sad.So many memories can be made in the span of just a couple of months without school, and during the summer before my sophomore year of high school, I made some memories at the ballpark.My dad, brother, and I took a 10-day trip that started in Boston and included a trip to the beautiful Fenway Park, which I had never been to before.
Dodgers: Former LA Outfielder Billy McKinney Signs with Yankees
Billy McKinney is 28 years old and has played in the big leagues in each of the last five seasons.Somehow, despite being a first-round draft pick by the A's in 2013 and a top-100 prospect in both 2015 and 2016, McKinney has played for six different big-league teams in his five seasons.As of right now, it doesn't look like the lefty outfielder will add a seventh team, as he recently signed with the team he made his major-league debut with, the New York Yankees.
With the sting of the Yankees ' postseason exit still smarting, some uplifting content still feels appropriate.There will be ample time during the offseason to conduct a full postmortem on what went wrong where they go from here; for now, we're still looking back on the moments - good and bad - that characterized the season.
MLB Insider Explores Trade Market, The Dodgers Need To Be In On These Guys
The MLB trade deadline is rapidly approaching, and this one is sure to be interesting.There are tons of buyers, as teams look to make a late push up the standings and into the expanded postseason.However, there aren't very many sellers.The two teams most obviously set to be sellers - the Oakland Athletics and Kansas City Royals - don't have much to offer, and after that, it's hard to know which teams will look to sell.
Dodgers Free Agency Rumors: Aroldis Chapman Not Offered 2-Year Contract
Along with traditional MLB insiders, free agency reports this offseason have come from Carlos Baerga, who recently said Aroldis Chapman received a two-year contract offer from the Los Angeles Dodgers.On the surface, there was one reason to believe the Dodgers held interest in the left-hander as they don't have a clear-cut closer in place.
Dodgers Reportedly Have Offer On Table to Aroldis Chapman
Aroldis Chapman was once the most dominant relief pitcher in baseball, with a fastball that routinely hit triple digits and a devastating slider.The Dodgers almost traded for Chapman after the 2015 season, but reports of a domestic violence incident (for which he was later suspended 30 games) caused them to back out of the deal.
Noah Syndergaard Will Prove to be the Steal of the Offseason
We did it!We did it!Everyone rejoice!The Dodgers have officially signed RHP Noah Syndergaard to a one-year deal!If you're an avid reader of dodgersnation.com, an avid watcher of Dodgers Nation Youtube or an active follower of me on Twitter (@noahcamras), you've probably heard me mention the Dodgers signing RHP Noah Syndergaard this offseason.
Former Dodger Kenley Jansen Keeps Getting it Done in October
Former Dodgers closer Kenley Jansen is with the Braves now, and unlike his replacement in Los Angeles, Kenley actually made his team's postseason roster.
Mookie Betts recalls the last Red Sox-Yankees brawl: 'I'm a lover, not a fighter'
Red Sox "I think the Red Sox-Yankees rivalry is probably the best in sports."The rivalry between the Red Sox and Yankee s has lost some of its fastball over the last few years.Just don't tell that to former Red Sox star Mookie Betts."I think the Red Sox-Yankees rivalry is probably the best in sports," Betts told Yankees OF Aaron Judge during Bleacher Report's "On Base With Mookie Betts" last week.
CloseESPN MLB insider Author of "The Arm: Inside the Billion-Dollar Mystery of the Most Valuable Commodity in Sports"
The Boston Red Sox acquired shortstop Adalberto Mondesi from the Kansas City Royals for left-handed reliever Josh Taylor on Tuesday, providing middle-infield depth to buttress losses this winter to free agency and injury.
MLB.com | Bryan Hoch: As you likely know by now, the Yankees and White Sox didn't take the field last night due to dangerously poor air quality.The teams are now scheduled to play a single-admission doubleheader today starting at 4 p.m. EST.Should poor conditions delay or postpone play again, we'll have you updated.
Every day, Pinstripe Alley offers updates on what the ' top American League opponents are up to through the Rivalry Roundup.The AL East is well-trodden ground there, but with the month of May coming to a close, we're going to take a peak around MLB as a whole and check in with each of the other five divisions.
The AL East in 2023 is a gauntlet.It has proven itself to be the best division in baseball, with teams boasting MVPs, All-Stars, and top-flight young talent.Unfortunately for the Yankees, and fortunately for baseball fans, it appears that this division projects to be good for the foreseeable future.
Every day, Pinstripe Alley offers updates on what the ' top American League opponents are up to through the Rivalry Roundup.The AL East is well-trodden ground there, but with the month of April coming to a close, we're going to take a peak around MLB as a whole and check in with each of the other five divisions.
ESPN | Buster Olney: Aaron Judge is the reigning AL MVP and newly-minted Yankees captain, but it appears he wears another hat as well.According to Buster Olney, principal owner Hal Steinbrenner consults Judge on team-related matters.He's weighed in on spring training facility improvements and provided evaluations of the team's top prospects.
FanGraphs | Jay Jaffe: It's been a bad start to spring training for the Yankee rotation with news that Frankie Montas will undergo surgery and Nestor Cortes will require extra time to overcome a bum hamstring (though the latter did throw a bullpen yesterday).Much was made of the strength of the pitching staff over the course of the offseason, where it was projected to be the game's best, but relying on Clarke Schmidt and Domingo Germán take some bites out of that potential.
Why Kansas City Royals closer Scott Barlow treasures his 50th career save in the majors
Kansas City Royals closer Scott Barlow still remembers his first MLB save.It was part of an infamous scuffle between the Royals and the Chicago White Sox.The game featured high emotion, ejections and a lot of drama.In the 10th inning on April 17, 2019, Barlow took the mound with exuberance.It was his 11th career appearance and the Royals needed him in a big spot.
3 takeaways from the Chicago White Sox's disappointing series against the last-place Kansas City Royals, including another injury scare
The bottom of the ninth inning began with an always troublesome walk Thursday at Kauffman Stadium.It concluded with a perfect bunt and with that the end of a disappointing series for the Chicago White Sox.Afterward, manager Pedro Grifol got straight to the point."We got outplayed in the series," Grifol said.
Fermin's bunt in ninth gives Royals 4-3 win over White Sox
KANSAS CITY, Mo. (AP) - Freddy Fermin had fouled off a couple of bunt attempts earlier in the week, yet Royals manager Matt Quatraro had no qualms about calling for another one with the backup catcher at the plate and a chance to beat the White Sox on Thursday.This time, Fermin's bunt was fair.Nick Pratto immediately dashed home from third base, but the bunt was so perfectly executed that there was never even a play, and that allowed Kansas City to escape with a 4-3 victory over Chicago and its first home series win of the season.
'We got outplayed': 3 takeaways from the Chicago White Sox's disappointing series against the last-place Kansas City Royals
The bottom of the ninth inning began with an always troublesome walk Thursday at Kauffman Stadium.It concluded with a perfect bunt and with that the end of a disappointing series for the Chicago White Sox.Afterward, manager Pedro Grifol got straight to the point."We got outplayed in the series," Grifol said.
We'd best hope that whatever demons accosted Dylan Cease in Surprise tonight don't plan on accompanying him back to colder climates.Whether it stemmed from pitch clock-inspired urgency or just regular old bad command, tonight's version of Cease was an ugly throwback to one of his bad outings before 2022.
The Guardians cut their payroll to the bone and were supposed to not be very good, and instead won the division by 11 games.The White Sox were supposed to be really good last year, but weren't.Their big offseason move was to sign a pitcher who's under investigation for domestic violence.The Twins signed a big free agent before 2021 and hoped to contend, but didn't.
Old faces in new places: The former Yankees wearing new jerseys in 2023
Spring training games are officially underway, and all 30 teams are starting to get rolling.With that, players that have changed clubs have settled into their new digs.Though the Yankees didn't see a ton of turnover during the last offseason, there were still a number of players that left for other pastures.
CBS Sports | R.J. Anderson: The long, strange, and often troubling Yankees career of Aroldis Chapman has formally come to an end, as the left-handed former flamethrower signed a one year contract worth $3.75 million with the Kansas City Royals (pending a physical, of course).The 13-year veteran is coming off the worst season of his career, during which he saw himself lose the closer job to breakout reliever Clay Holmes, miss time due to an infected tattoo, and finally, amidst rumors that the team contemplated designating him for assignment in September, decide not to show up to a mandatory workout prior to the postseason.
Braves News: Atlanta signs Kevin Pillar, Baseball America top 100
The Braves made one of their bigger transactions of the offseason on Wednesday.That isn't to say that signing Kevin Pillar to a minor league deal is a big move, but that if he does make the opening day roster, he would get more money than any other free agent signing by the organization this offseason.
Changeup specialist Tommy Kahnle's return meshes nicely with the Yankees
I do so enjoy free agency.Every time my phone buzzes, I wonder whether this time it is a push notification that the Yankees have signed someone.And this morning, I was not betrayed, with Brian Cashman inking Tommy Kahnle, bringing him back for a second tour of duty in the Yankee bullpen (and third in the organization as a whole).
Ken Rosenthal of The Athleticrecently reported that the Tigers will be likely suppliers to teams searching for impact bullpen arms.The team has a solid stock of relievers and looks at least a year away from contention, so this winter could be the perfect window to cash in on an area of surplus.He named three relievers in particular, the first of whom - Joe Jiménez - I covered on Thursday, so today we'll move on to his teammate Gregory Soto.
Associated Press | Ronald Blum: Aaron Judge is now officially a free agent.With the Astros' World Series win on Saturday night, it's officially the offseason, and on Sunday all 131 players entering free agency across the majors were announced.Judge, Jacob deGrom, and Carlos Correa headline this year's free agent class, and all players can begin signing with teams on Friday.
Let's flash back in time to 2015.The Kansas City Royals had just won the World Series.The year before they nearly won it again.A strong core of talented players, a dedicated fan base, and a franchise that had bucked the trend of mega markets winning the World Series.Life was good.That was a long time ago.
Braves News: Painful loss, Jackson Stephens update, more
Well the Braves had a game on Saturday and it was fun to watch until the bottom of the ninth happened, which was absolutely excruciating to watch, culminating in a five pitch walk-off walk loss.
Another day of domestic-violence stories in sports, one involving the White Sox' Mike Clevinger
You wake up and read the sports news like you always do.You wait for what you know is coming, because it always does.It doesn't take long to learn that four male athletes have been accused of domestic violence in separate incidents.This was Tuesday, but it could have been any day of the week ending in "day.''
Heading into the last third of January, there's much ado about nothing going on right now.Tangentially related to the Yankees at this point has been the reliever market, where Aroldis Chapman moved on to the Royals of all teams (seems most of the contenders are understandably hesitant on him), and Zack Britton held a throwing session for teams recently.
Next-Best Yankees Playoff Games of the Past 25 Years: Hicks, Paxton keep season alive
A common theme throughout this series has been that a Yankees series loss doesn't negate the great victories that occurred along the way.Everybody knows Derek Jeter's Mr. November moment, and the comeback in Game 4 of the 2017 ALCS announced the arrival of the Baby Bombers era (even if the era didn't quite go as planned, it was still fun).
25 Best Yankees Playoff Games of the Past 25 Years: A Tanaka gem and a Bird bomb
There are must-win games, and there are must-win games.Heading into Game 3 of the ALDS in 2017, the Yankees were coming off a loss as heartbreaking as they come.It was do-or-die in Game 3, with Cleveland up two games to none.New York called on Masahiro Tanaka - the man who they signed in 2014 with playoff moments like this mind - and Cleveland went with their standout veteran, Carlos Carrasco.
2022 Yankees Least Valuable Player: Aroldis Chapman
The term "value" is tossed around an awful lot in the baseball world.The most important individual award even has the word in its name.The exact meaning of it is heavily disputed, however, and there are a lot of ways to interpret it, all of which can be at least partially correct.Thinking about value in the negative direction is no different.
We talked earlier this season about vibes.The thing about them is that when you're in a funk, or even a good vibe, it feels totally all-encompassing and impossible to escape.
New York Post | Dan Martin: Multiple injuries to key bullpen arms is not what you want so close to the playoffs, but one reinforcement returned in the form of Miguel Castro.
25 Best Yankees Playoff Games of the Past 25 Years: Didi caps ALDS comeback in Cleveland
The Yankees seemed dead and buried through the first two games of the 2017 ALDS.After getting shutout in the series opener, they seemed destined to get back to New York tied, only to meltdown and eventually lose that game in extra innings.That put them in a 2-0 hole to Cleveland, who were the top seed in the AL and had gone on a 22-game winning streak during the year, with no iota of wiggle room.
Previewing the Yankees' qualifying offer decisions
The Yankees ' season ended weeks ago, but their first set of offseason decisions is set to come tomorrow.November 10th is the deadline for teams to tender qualifying offers to their free agents.With 10 players hitting free agency, this stands as an important day for the Yankees, as how their particular QO scenarios work out will hold some influence over the shape of their offseason.
Yankees activate Scott Effross, option Greg Weissert
The Yankees are finally getting healthy, and it couldn't come at a better time.In recent weeks, we've seen the roster reinforced by returning players from Anthony Rizzo to Luis Severino.
A career journeyman who played for five different teams in his first seven seasons, Ryan Weber has been one of the most active riders of the Scranton Shuttle this season.
NJ.com | Mike Rosenstein: Long-rumored to be one of the main suitors for Aaron Judge this winter, the Giants didn't exactly throw their hat in the ring yesterday, but the club's president Farhan Zaidi confirmed that San Fran will be big spenders in the winter, as they attempt to claw back from a bad 2022.
Pinstripe Alley Podcast Ep. 170: Judge Finally Gets Some Help
Kunj is back on the PSA Podcast and thankfully, the Yankees have done their best over the past several days to assuage some doubts that their mini-winning streak last week wasn't merely typical Twins nonsense.
MLB.com | Bryan Hoch: The New York Yankees formally re-introduced superstar outfielder Aaron Judge yesterday morning at Yankee Stadium, as the slugger officially re-signed with the team that drafted him.As part of those proceedings, Hal Steinbrenner made official what everybody anticipated when the news of his nine-year deal broke two weeks ago, naming Aaron Judge the 16th captain of the New York Yankees.
The Yankees have a solid bullpen foundation already.You could say with confidence that it's consistently been their deepest unit for some time.The team's lineup or rotation may have down years, but the bullpen always produces.So far, New York has Clay Holmes, Tommy Kahnle, Wandy Peralta, Jonathan Loáisiga, Lucas Luetge, and Lou Trivino likely penciled in for slots, with other young guns and recovering arms (think Michael King) also in the mix.
White Sox sign Andrew Benintendi to five-year deal
The Yankees have done a good job this offseason at checking off important items on their to-do list.They brought back Anthony Rizzo to fortify first base, and more importantly, they also convinced MVP Aaron Judge to return as well, thanks to a big nine-year contract.They took steps to improve their already-accomplished pitching staff as well, replacing Jameson Taillon with Carlos Rodón just last night, and to a less-important extent, swapping in old friend Tommy Kahnle for the likes of Aroldis Chapman, Miguel Castro, and Zack Britton in the bullpen.
Yankees add bullpen upside by reuniting with Tommy Kahnle
Tommy Kahnle quickly became a fan favorite during his previous stint with the Yankees, and a full year recovered from Tommy John surgery finds himself back in the Bronx, signing a two-year, $11.5 million deal with New York today.The 33-year-old posted a 2.84 ERA, 2.39 xERA and 4.38 FIP, the latter number dragged by some bad home run luck in just 12 innings in 2022.
Ah, December.The temperatures are dropping, students are fretting over exams, and Mariah Carey blasts fifty times a day through every store in the mall while you get an early jump on your holiday shopping.You know what that means?That's right, it's time for our monthly ritual here at Pinstripe Alley, where we ask you, our dear readers, to tell us your thoughts on Yankees "Not technically under contract but still acting as general manager anyway" Brian Cashman.
Yankees Potential Free Agent Target: Andrew Chafin
As a contending team, the Yankees ' No. 1 priority should be securing the signature of star outfielder Aaron Judge on a long-term contract.Everything else is secondary - albeit still important - because having the reigning AL MVP will almost guarantee that the Bombers are a playoff-caliber team.Subtract him, and it's not so obvious anymore.
The Miami Marlins have a busy off-season ahead of us and we do have a path to the playoffs next season.We definitely have the ace for that.What about our bullpen though?We clearly need to add some arms.So, who could we add?Who are some good options for The Fish to pursue this off-season?Let's take a look at our list of options and consider who we should target.
While Aaron Judge and to a lesser extent Anthony Rizzo have dominated the Yankees hot stove this winter, the bullpen entered the postseason a bit of a question mark.Although the loss of Zack Britton and Aroldis Chapman to free agency isn't exactly a loss - and may even be counted as an improvement - the current relief corps of Clay Holmes, Wandy Peralta, Jonathan Loaísigia, and Michael King need some reinforcement if the Yankees want to continue having one of the league's premier bullpens.
When the Yankees traded for Clay Holmes last year, many in the fanbase were outraged.While this was not necessarily because of Holmes himself - most of the anger was directed towards the team's decision to trade Hoy Park, who had been raking in Triple-A - his 4.93 ERA in 44 games with the Pirates didn't help matters.
NJ.com | Bridget Hyland: The Yankees should be doing everything they can to retain the services of Aaron Judge, but they're far from the only potential landing spot.While media members are skeptical that the Mets will be very active in Judge's free agency case, the Giants are widely expected to pursue him, and Jeff Passan is among those speculating that the Red Sox could wade into the waters as well.
How Thursday's rainout will affect the remainder of the ALDS
The rainout of Game 2 on Thursday and rescheduling to Friday throws a bit of a wrench into the pitching plans for the Yankees and Guardians, as the teams face the prospect of playing four games in four days - with flights to and from Cleveland - should the series advance that far.
Aroldis Chapman shouldn't have a postseason roster spot
In the simplest way, Chapman is not a very good or trustworthy pitcher right now, and hasn't done much to earn a postseason roster spot with this team.On Sunday afternoon against the Orioles, Chapman recorded just one out, giving up a hit, three walks, and two earned runs, saddling him with the loss.Essentially, it's not like the Yankees are just totally hopeless and simply must use Chapman; it would be possible and perhaps advantageous for them to leave the former All-Star off the roster.With one final series against the Rangers remaining in the regular season, the postseason is just about upon the Yankees.
Aroldis Chapman is back with the Yankees, so what can fans reasonably expect?
For many Yankee fans, no player inspires more eye rolls than when Aroldis Chapman comes to the mound.In the last few years, he has defined the term mercurial.
NJ.com | Randy Miller: The offseason hardware is rolling in, and Aaron Judge has earned his first of the year.Judge was named the AL Hank Aaron Award winner, recognizing the best offensive player in the league according to a fan vote as well as a panel of Hall of Fame players.Judge joins former Yankees Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez as winners since the award's induction in 1999, and it bodes well for his AL MVP case concluding a week later.
Just before Opening Day was set to take place, the Yankees made a couple of trades to shake up their roster.One netted them their All-Star starting catcher for the year, while the other brought in a veteran reliever by the name of Miguel Castro.Castro was the bigger name at that time, and it was a bit of a surprise that the Mets opted to swap relievers with their cross-town neighbors, but by the end of the year Castro's impact on the 2022 season would be a minimal one.
The Yankees bullpen is in a good place heading into the offseason
During the first half of the season, the Yankees bullpen was arguably the best in the league.Aside from Chad Green getting hurt, injuries hadn't really affected the relief corps that much, and many of the main arms plus some unexpected contributors were dealing.The unit had a 2.89 ERA (second-best in MLB) and a league-best 3.05 FIP before the break.
The 2022 season will stick in the memories of Yankees fans for years to come.Yesterday, we recapped the five highlights of the year.Today being Halloween, it felt appropriate to take a walk down the dark and shrouded paths in our minds and remember the five moments that will haunt our memories all winter.
One of the most heart-rending times for any baseball fan is when a player with uncertain command and control of the ball enters the game in relief.Suddenly you have a reliever throwing the ball at 100+ mph with no idea where the ball will land.Is it going to land 40 feet in front of home plate, above the umpire's head, or somewhere altogether else?
The Anthony Rizzo negotiations are important to Yankees future
The New York Yankees have once again been tossed out of the postseason by the Houston Astros, and now that the offseason is here, decisions need to be made by general manager Brian Cashman and the team brass about the roster.According to Jim Bowden, a player of the utmost importance in Anthony Rizzo is expected to opt out of his $16 million player option for the coming season.
The idea of a gold glove for a pitcher is fundamentally a weird concept.Pitchers very rarely make any defensive plays (except for you know, pitching), but they will occasionally run into the ball.
This Yankees staff is wildly different than most recent ones
With Gerrit Cole, Nestor Cortes, and Luis Severino atop the rotation and a pair of starters in Jameson Taillon and Domingo Germán working out of the bullpen in the ALDS, the 2022 Yankees have placed a lot of emphasis on their starting pitching this October.
Pinstripe Alley Podcast Ep. 174: ALDS Showdown with Cleveland
The Yankees thankfully got to sit out the Wild Card Series weekend and await their ALDS opponent, and now we know who they'll be playing tomorrow night in the Bronx.
Aaron Judge shows frustration, still 61 homers with 2 games left | amNewYork
ARLINGTON, Texas (AP) - Aaron Judge slammed his helmet in a rare show of frustration and the Yankees slugger remained at 61 home runs with just two games remaining to break the AL record after New York beat Texas 5-4 Tuesday to open a day-night doubleheader.
Prior to tonight's game, the Yankees made the following roster moves:* Returned from rehab and reinstated RHP Miguel Castro (#30) from the 60-day injured list.New York Yankees (@Yankees)
October 3, 2022
It's a tough fate for González, who pitched well enough yesterday, but the move is not surprising.If he can toss a couple clean inning in Texas, then the Yankees could carry him as one of the last members of their bullpen in the ALDS.He gave the Yankees exactly what they wanted, quality innings, and now they keep making moves, with an eye on the playoffs.
Josh Donaldson drives in winning run as Yankees beat Red Sox 5-4 in extra innings | amNewYork
Josh Donaldson drove in the game-winning run in the bottom of the 10th inning as the Yankees defeated the Boston Red Sox 5-4 and clinched their spot in the postseason.
Yankees activate Zack Britton, send Wandy Peralta to IL
Yankees fans already knew that the team was about to get a bullpen boost in the form of trade deadline acquisition Scott Effross for the opener of a four-game set against the Red Sox on Thursday night.
On bullpen volatility and managing the unmanageable
The Yankees have built a reputation for bullpen excellence.Ever since Mariano Rivera rose to prominence decades ago, the team has almost always sported a strong relief unit.
Zack Britton's potential return could give the Yankees bullpen an edge
The Yankees bullpen has been ravaged by injuries and unexpected stars underperforming this year.The situation has tested the team's overall pitching depth, and they haven't always aced that test.
Triple-A Scranton is making an incredible run at a division crown after falling to a big deficit early in the season, while Double-A Somerset received some big-name cameos this week from rehabbing major leaguers.
...
He will almost certainly start next season in High-A, and could be fast tracked to Double-A by mid-season if his play remains strong.
Outfielder Harrison Bader made his Yankees organization debut yesterday afternoon with a rehab outing with Double-A Somerset; also appearing in that game were a trio of relievers - Zack Britton, Miguel Castro, and Aroldis Chapman.
Yankees place Andrew Benintendi on IL, recall Estevan Florial
The moment that Andrew Benintendi grimaced in pain while taking a third-inning swing during Friday night's loss, it looked like he could be in serious trouble.