Arizona's execution pitted experts against politicians. Experts lost | Austin Sarat
Briefly

Aaron Gunches was executed in Arizona after a lengthy, controversial legal battle that included his changing decisions about appealing. Governor Katie Hobbs made headlines when she expedited his execution by dismissing retired Judge David Duncan, who was conducting a review of the state's death penalty procedures. This decision raised questions about the integrity of the review process and fueled concerns about political motivations overshadowing factual assessments related to execution protocols in the state. Critics argue this reflects a troubling trend of sidelining fact for expediency in capital cases.
Your review has, unfortunately, faced repeated challenges, and I no longer have confidence that I will receive a report from you that will accomplish the purpose and goals of the Executive Order that I issued nearly two years ago.
Hobbs tossed Duncan aside because she didn't like the facts he was finding or the conclusions he seemed to be reaching.
In our era, facts can be tossed aside with little political cost and no regret.
Still, Hobbs's unprecedented decision to kill the messenger was another low moment for a society increasing living.
Read at www.theguardian.com
[
|
]