Starmer's immigration rhetoric follows familiar pattern of bold claims but few results, expert says

"Governments of all stripes like to make bold claims, from 'stop the boats' and 'smash the gangs' to 'net migration falling below 100,000'. In practice, the results have disappointed, because factors outside their control have played a huge role."

"Successive ministers have felt unable to be honest with the public about the possibility that their policies may not work, which has led to a cycle of unfulfilled promises."

Keir Starmer's commitment to dismantle gangs involved in small boat crossings reflects a pattern of ambitious rhetoric from previous Conservative governments. Expert Madeleine Sumption notes that such claims often lack evidence of feasibility, as they depend on factors beyond government control. The UK and France are negotiating to address people-smuggling, while Starmer faces criticism for not reducing the number of arrivals. Historical context shows that previous promises, like reducing net migration, have often led to disappointing results due to external influences and the complexities of smuggling operations.

Read at www.theguardian.com