Opponents of assisted dying in Scotland argue that the proposal is ethically troubling, asserting that it changes the role of the state from preserving life to enabling death. Campaigners, including Liz Carr and disabled MSP Pam Duncan-Glancy, explicitly disagree with framing the debate around personal autonomy and choice. They argue that this legislation, if passed, would push against ethical boundaries as instead of ensuring robust palliative care, it provides a legal means for the state to assist in taking lives. A free vote is scheduled for MSPs to discuss the bill, which allows assisted dying under specific medical conditions, but notable political figures, including former first ministers, have expressed doubts about its provisions around coercion and patient safeguards.
Pam Duncan-Glancy emphasized that supporting assisted dying legislation crosses a significant ethical line, as it allows the state to facilitate someone's death rather than focusing on ensuring quality of life.
Former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon expressed concern about the inability to prevent coercion in the bill, highlighting the complexities involved in such a legal change and the potential risks.
Collection
[
|
...
]