One Chick-Fil-A Secret Menu Sandwich Channels In-N-Out - Tasting Table

In-N-Out’s Double Double features two beef patties, American cheese, onions, lettuce, tomato, and Thousand Island-style secret sauce on a toasted bun. A similar layered flavor can be created at Chick-fil-A by ordering a double Spicy Chicken Sandwich and requesting two chicken breasts, with both grilled and fried options marinated with peppers. The sandwich can be built with Chick-fil-A sauce, made from honey mustard, barbecue, and ranch, to resemble the spread. Adding onions and choosing American cheese instead of colby jack creates a fried chicken version of the double-patty burger. Ordering deluxe ensures cheese, and a second chicken breast increases the price. Waffle fries are recommended as the best side. Minor upgrades include swapping colby jack for pepper jack and adding extra sauce such as Polynesian sauce.

"When you order a Chick-fil-A spicy chicken sandwich, simply ask for two chicken breasts - both the grilled and fried versions are marinated with peppers for a touch of heat. Then get it with a side of Chick-fil-A sauce (a mixture of honey mustard, barbecue, and ranch) to mimic In-N-Out's special spread. If you add onions, and order it with American cheese instead of colby jack, you'll have yourself a fried chicken version of the juicy double-patty burger."

"Pro tips: Make sure it's deluxe so you get the cheese. And keep in mind that ordering a second chicken breast takes the price from around $7 to more than $10, depending on your location. It's not on the actual menu, but you can request it at the drive-thru or on your mobile order - it might just come in a separate container. And don't forget the waffle fries, the best side on Chick-fil-A's menu."

"Our reviewer switched the colby jack for pepper jack for a little extra heat and appreciated how the lettuce and tomato adds freshness. But if you want some extra sauce action, Reddit users on the r/ChickFilA thread have a few suggestions. One mentioned adding Polynesian sauce to the spicy sandwich"

Read at Tasting Table