The top three winners for the best burgers in Staten Island are The Buttery in Castleton Corners, Z-Two in Charleston, and Sally's Southern in West Brighton. This year's voting followed a nomination period that received 59 submissions. Over the next two weeks, coverage will focus on what makes these restaurants popular among readers. The Best of Staten Island includes various categories throughout the year, highlighting local businesses, with previous categories such as breakfast, tacos, and sandwiches being featured already.
The top three winners of the Best of Staten Island 2025 for burgers are The Buttery in Castleton Corners, Z-Two in Charleston, and Sally's Southern in West Brighton.
The process for selecting the Best of Staten Island includes one week of nominations, one week of voting, followed by two weeks of coverage of the top winners.
The Best of Staten Island initiative features seven categories throughout the year, with previous categories including the best dance schools, breakfast, and tacos.
Only brick-and-mortar businesses are eligible for nomination, ensuring that readers vote for established local eateries.
Collection
[
|
...
]