In his Netflix special Selective Outrage, Chris Rock pointedly critiques the hypocrisy in social justice discourse, observing that even those who preach 'wokeness' do so from a privilege. The act of typing 'woke' tweets, he notes, is facilitated by technologies often linked to exploitative practices, like child labor. This sharp observation underscores a broader contradiction within social-justice advocacy, where the lofty ideals espoused often conflict with the uncomfortable realities of everyday life.
Musa al-Gharbi's We Have Never Been Woke highlights how political disillusionment is mirrored in the socio-economic disparities observed in urban liberal settings. He emphasizes a starkly racialized caste system where highly underpaid workers, often immigrants or people of color, serve those in positions of privilege. Al-Gharbi contrasts this with his previous experiences in a working-class environment, pointing out that even the most egregious societal inequities are more pronounced among the liberal elite who publicly champion equality.
Al-Gharbi’s argument sheds light on a societal hypocrisy: those who vocally support social justice initiatives often are the same individuals who benefit from the systems of exploitation. He suggests that the context of urban environments allows for a denser network of exploitation that isn't as apparent in less diverse, working-class settings. The contrast he draws between these two worlds highlights how the pursuit of social justice can sometimes be more performative than substantive, particularly among those at the top.
Lastly, the article notes how the reelection prospects of figures like Donald Trump can be seen as a backlash against the rising awareness of social inequalities. Al-Gharbi posits that the disconnect between the rhetoric of progressive elites and the lived experiences of many Americans can create political outcomes that further complicate the quest for genuine social justice reform. This disillusionment often leads back to the same systemic issues that the social-justice movement aims to address.
Collection
[
|
...
]