Brian McCann had a solid career, making seven All-Star teams and winning six Silver Sluggers, but his overall impact is overshadowed by other catchers.
Dustin Pedroia showcased a high peak in his career, winning an MVP award and achieving six seasons with a bWAR over 5.0, despite injury setbacks.
While both McCann and Pedroia had impressive statistics and accolades, Pedroia's career bWAR of 51.9 and postseason success may stand out more.
Pedroia's career was marred by injuries, cutting it short at 34, but his high peak and accolades ensure he'll get Hall of Fame consideration.
Collection
[
|
...
]