Vance's memoir simplifies Appalachian struggles into a narrative of cultural failure, ignoring deeper issues such as disinvestment and exploitative industries, which misguides public perception.
Despite my initial expectations, I found Vance to be intelligent and gracious, demonstrating a willingness to engage with criticism that ultimately shifted the debate in his favor.
Vance embodies a duality: while alarmingly conservative on issues like abortion and immigration, he also aligns with progressive populism, reflecting a complex political identity.
The risk for progressives today is in underestimating Vance; dismissing him as a mere corporate tool overlooks his genuine populist appeal which engages a broad audience.
[
Collection
]
[
|
...
]