In the debut episode of 'Everybody's Live with John Mulaney,' the comedian attempts to reinvent the late-night talk show genre, but the result feels more like confusion than clarity. While Mulaney's past experiences in comedy and his live format add intrigue, the execution often falters, lacking the excitement it aims to generate. The show balances between parody and traditional formats, leading to an uncomfortable atmosphere that stifles creativity. Despite having standout moments, particularly Mulaney's self-reflective monologue about his past addiction, the show ultimately fails to provide a fresh perspective on the late-night genre.
Mulaney's monologue was the high point Wednesday, as the star referenced his past struggles with addiction. 'It's my live, jazz-like unpredictable talk show,' he cracked.
Instead of lending an air of danger or anything-can-happen excitement, the show's live element just added an overarching pressure which seemed to stifle the proceedings.
Mulaney seemed perfectly poised to find a new way to make an ancient genre relevant for streaming TV. However, the result felt more like parody.
The offhand, randomly eccentric vibe distilled in Mulaney's debut didn't feel like a bold reinvention of talk shows, but rather an uncomfortable middle ground.
Collection
[
|
...
]