Why Some Shoppers Have Given Up On Trader Joe's Milk - Tasting Table

"Every time I have purchased milk, cream or whipping cream at Trader Joe's, it has been bad almost as soon as I bought it. Always before the sell-by date. This recurring complaint appears across multiple customer accounts, with entire Reddit threads dedicated to the problem of whole milk spoiling too quickly, with dozens of comments sharing similar experiences of milk going off soon after purchase."

"The organic 2% milk from Trader Joe's tastes like there's chlorine in it. Another said it had a plastic flavor. Someone else described it as oily. Many commenters point out that Trader Joe's doesn't operate its own dairy farms. Instead, it sources from local dairies. So, depending on where you are in the country, you're going to have different experiences with the milk."

Milk consumption in America has declined significantly since the 1970s, with average annual consumption dropping from nearly 32 gallons to approximately 16 gallons today. Trader Joe's faces persistent customer complaints about milk quality issues. Multiple customers report that milk, cream, and whipping cream spoil well before their sell-by dates. Beyond spoilage concerns, shoppers describe unusual tastes including chlorine, plastic, and oily flavors. Trader Joe's sources milk from local dairies rather than operating its own farms, resulting in varying product quality depending on geographic location. These quality issues are particularly notable given that Trader Joe's ranks relatively low among organic milk brands.

Read at Tasting Table