"Konami's "Silent Hill 2" is an exceptional, even historic work of horror media - but you wouldn't know it judging by the game's baffling new adaptation from Cineverse and Iconic Events. A nasty, claustrophobic display that's packed with incomplete ideas, "Return to Silent Hill" squanders the rare opportunity to translate one of PlayStation's most psychologically sophisticated worlds into box office fuel."
"Trapped in the same artistic era as he was then, and chasing even worse market instincts now, the result is a deeper failure that reflects industry regression on several levels. Gans and his distributors demonstrate little understanding of what made the source material endure ("Silent Hill 2" was popular enough to inspire a critically acclaimed remake that hit consoles in 2024), while simultaneously failing to speak the basic language of cinema that cmoviegoers who don't know IP."
"Collapsing under the weight of its own confusion, "Return to Silent Hill" is perversely fascinating to watch in moments. Gans' long-gestating comeback manifests as a relic that's less an artifact of the Konami franchise itself than it is pointless debris ripped from a time when Hollywood mistook aesthetic fidelity and toxic self-importance for understanding the stories that truly compel genre gamers."
Return to Silent Hill offers a claustrophobic, idea-fragmented reboot that fails to translate Silent Hill 2's psychological sophistication into film. Christophe Gans returns after two decades but remains trapped in an outdated artistic era and worse market instincts, producing a deeper failure that signals industry regression. The filmmakers demonstrate little understanding of the source material while also failing to communicate basic cinematic language to general moviegoers. The film favors foggy surreality and aesthetic homage over psychological and spatial logic, resulting in hollow subculture recognition that replaces resonance with exposition and familiar iconography with empty fear.
Read at IndieWire
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]