Butter Vs Oil: Which Is The Better Choice For Cornbread Mix? - Tasting Table

"Since cornbread mix involves a relatively simple ingredient list, including cornmeal, flour, sugar, leavening, and salt, butter is essential for adding flavor depth. Neutral-tasting cooking oils could allow the sweetness of the corn and sugar in the bread to come through. However, for me, this translates to one-dimensional, bland taste. Butter uplifts the corn's flavor and gives way to the bread's signature savory-sweetness."

"Sure, some prominent chefs like Duff Goldman bake their cornbread with vegetable oil instead of butter, citing textural reasons. Oil can help achieve a moist, fluffy cornbread since, unlike butter, it doesn't contain water, which can make bakes dense. But I find that butter still results in a moist cornbread when combined with milk or buttermilk, as boxed mixes often suggest."

Cornbread mixes use simple ingredients like cornmeal, flour, sugar, leavening, and salt. Butter adds flavor depth that complements corn's natural sweetness and prevents a one-dimensional taste. Vegetable oil produces a lighter, fluffier crumb because it lacks water, which can keep baked goods moist. Combining butter with milk or buttermilk delivers moisture while retaining richer flavor. A slightly tighter crumb from butter can be advantageous for dipping into chili or spreading additional butter. Many traditional recipes and boxed mixes indicate butter as a key ingredient for balanced cornbread flavor.

Read at Tasting Table