How To Enhance An Old Fashioned With Simple Swaps, According To A Mixologist - Tasting Table

"Without ruining what makes an old fashioned an old fashioned, you have to focus on its core ingredients and think of them like parts of a song - small changes create an entirely new sound. Bitters are the easiest place to start. Swapping out traditional aromatic bitters for something like peach bitters instantly introduces a new layer of flavor without compromising the structure of the drink."

"To add depth and warmth, replace the standard sugar cube or simple syrup with maple syrup for depth and warmth while keeping the cocktail balanced. I typically reach for high-proof bourbons with a higher rye content to give the drink backbone and spice."

The old fashioned remains an iconic cocktail with enduring appeal, yet its simple recipe allows for creative variations. Curtis McMillan, creative director at The Down Low Cocktail Club, explains that successful modifications require treating the drink's components like parts of a song, where small changes create new flavors without compromising structure. Bitters offer the easiest starting point for experimentation, with alternatives like peach bitters adding new dimensions. Sweetener can be swapped from traditional sugar to maple syrup for added depth and warmth. The bourbon base itself presents opportunities, with high-proof varieties featuring higher rye content providing backbone and spice. This approach balances creativity with respect for the original recipe.

Read at Tasting Table