The Moral Life of Organs in an Age of Technological Innovation

"In medicine, technology can refer to anything from antibiotics like penicillin used to treat everyday infections and antivirals that suppress HIV, to dialysis circuits and cardiopulmonary bypass pumps. More broadly, technology is the machinery and methods developed through scientific knowledge to solve practical problems. Organ transplant-the act of removing organs from one person's body to restore life in another-has, since its inception, depended on technology."

"Because the donor and recipient were identical twins, the challenge of immunologic compatibility was easily overcome. Yet the case raised questions about what happens when donor and recipient are not genetically identical, as well as from where organs can be obtained if not from living donors. Over the following decades, technological and medical breakthroughs transformed the field. Mechanical ventilation made it possible to maintain donors long enough for organ recovery and immunosuppressive therapies made long-term graft survival between non-genetically identical persons feasible."

"Today, complex computer-based logistics systems, portable perfusion platforms, and novel preservation techniques keep organs viable across greater distances and longer spans of time than ever before. The present inflection point is that, while exciting, new technology is being innovated and applied at a dramatic pace. The implementation of new technology in transplant is not only occurring quickly, but it is doing so with little discussion or input by the lay community, and virtually no oversight or regulation."

Medical technology spans simple antimicrobials to complex life-support machinery, and organ transplantation has relied on such technologies since its beginning. The first successful kidney transplant in 1954 between identical twins bypassed immunologic rejection but prompted questions about non-identical donors and organ sources. Subsequent advances—mechanical ventilation and immunosuppression—enabled donor maintenance and long-term graft survival across genetic differences. Contemporary tools, including computer logistics, portable perfusion platforms, and novel preservation techniques, extend organ viability across greater distances and times. Emerging practices like normothermic regional perfusion and ex vivo machine perfusion are becoming routine, while rapid implementation proceeds with minimal public input or regulation.

Read at Apaonline