UN rules ban use of force, yet could not stop the Iran war

"Article 2(4) of the UN Charter has been described as a "cornerstone of modern international law" and its bright red line. It prohibits countries from threatening or using force against another state's territory or political independence. Drafted in the aftermath of World War II, its objective was to maintain peace and make negotiation not armed conflict the default mode to settle disputes."

"Among the grounds cited by the United States and Israel for their recent "pre-emptive" strikes against Iran on February 28 were the need "to restrict its ballistic missile program" and "end its support of terrorist groups." Critics counter that these grounds did not fall within the UN Charter's exceptions, noting that only specific UN organs above all the Security Council can authoritively determine when force is lawful."

"In January 2026, UN special rapporteurs condemned the US intervention in Venezuela, in which US troops captured Venezuelan president Nicolas Maduro, as a "grave" and "deliberate" breach of Article 2(4). It also prompted United Nations Secretary General, Antonio Guterres, to warn that around the world "the rule of law is being replaced by the law of the jungle.""

Article 2(4) of the UN Charter, drafted after World War II, establishes a fundamental prohibition against states threatening or using force against another state's territory or political independence. This provision aims to make negotiation the default method for resolving disputes rather than armed conflict. The article has become central to international law and is frequently invoked during major geopolitical crises, including situations in Ukraine and the Middle East. Recent controversies highlight differing interpretations of the provision, particularly regarding pre-emptive strikes and military interventions. Critics argue that justifications for force must fall within UN Charter exceptions and only specific UN organs, particularly the Security Council, can authoritatively determine when force is lawful. UN officials have expressed concern that the rule of law is being undermined globally.

Read at www.dw.com