"Political scientists have long observed that countries are held together not by ideology but by organized coercion. That is, by the bureaucratic machinery, institutional memory and trained professionals who keep the lights on and the water running. Destroy that machinery, and you do not have a clean slate. You have a collapsed state, and collapsed states do not stay empty of leadership."
"Iran had been building that capacity in Iraq since the 1980s, cultivating Shia political networks, exile parties and militia groups during and after the Iran-Iraq War and beyond with the explicit goal of ensuring a post-Saddam Iraq would never again threaten Iranian security. Tehran did not need to build infrastructure in Iraq after the U.S. invasion, because it had spent the previous two decades building it."
"The fundamental misunderstanding at the heart of American regime-change strategy is the assumption that destroying the existing order creates space for something better. It does not. It creates space for whoever is best organized, best armed and most willing to fill it."
State cohesion depends on bureaucratic machinery and institutional capacity rather than ideology. When existing orders collapse through military intervention, power vacuums do not remain empty but are filled by whoever possesses the strongest organizational capacity. Iran exemplifies this pattern by cultivating networks in Iraq for two decades before the U.S. invasion, positioning itself to dominate post-Saddam Iraq. American-backed opposition groups like Ahmed Chalabi lacked domestic constituencies and organizational infrastructure. Military victories in Iraq and Libya created political catastrophes when no organized alternative existed to fill the resulting vacuums. The fundamental flaw in regime-change strategy assumes destruction creates space for improvement, when it actually creates space for the most organized, armed, and willing force to seize power.
#regime-change-strategy #state-collapse-and-power-vacuums #irans-regional-influence #institutional-capacity-and-governance #unintended-consequences-of-military-intervention
Read at Fortune
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]