Opinion: State's Democrats could sleep better if voters could rank gubernatorial choices

"Given our state's unique top-two primary system, there's a very real possibility that the vast Democratic field splits the vote and two Republicans end up on the November ballot. This is the nightmare scenario for California Democrats. It would leave voters selecting from two Republicans who potentially earned less than 40% of the primary vote combined."

"California voters adopted the top-two system in 2010 with hopes that it would give independents a voice and encourage candidates to reach beyond their base toward consensus and coalitions. Yet when the system is over-run with candidates, it can have the opposite effect, producing a fractured majority and two unrepresentative finalists."

"Perhaps the easiest and best solution would be adopting a top-four model similar to the one adopted by Alaska voters in 2020. Alaska sends the four highest finishers in its nonpartisan primary onto the general election all but ensuring that the general includes candidates from multiple perspectives."

California faces a potential scenario where two Republicans could advance to the general election for governor if the Democratic field remains fragmented. Despite Trump's low approval rating in California, polling shows no clear Democratic frontrunner among numerous candidates, while Republicans have consolidated around two top contenders. The state's top-two primary system, designed to encourage consensus-building and independent representation, can paradoxically produce unrepresentative outcomes when too many candidates compete. The Democratic state convention failed to narrow the field, leaving party insiders and donors to pressure candidates into dropping out before the June primary. Reforming the system by adopting a top-four model similar to Alaska's approach could better reflect voter intent and prevent fractured majorities.

Read at www.mercurynews.com