The upcoming conclave to elect a new pope after Pope Francis's death on May 7 has prompted a comparison to the movie 'Conclave,' which dramatizes the process. While the film captures the key logistics and elements of a papal election, experts caution that it takes significant liberties regarding character actions and certain ceremonial practices. For instance, while the voting process and smoke signaling are depicted correctly, stylistic choices such as cardinals' costumes and the portrayal of the ceremonial altar during Mass are misrepresented. Overall, 'Conclave' mixes authentic elements with fictional narratives.
While 'Conclave' captures the logistics and rituals of a papal election closely, it diverges in character involvement and some historical accuracy, according to experts.
The film represents the voting process and traditions well, but fails in depicting accurate priestly attire and specific ceremonial aspects, such as the altar used in Mass.
B. Kevin Brown from Gonzaga University remarked on the film's faithfulness to balloting and smoke signalling, yet noted significant inaccuracies around cardinals' conduct and attire.
Not every scandal or storyline portrayed in 'Conclave' has roots in the true events of papal elections, showcasing a creative and fictional twist.
Collection
[
|
...
]