There is no denying Labour is in crisis but in a strange way, Keir Starmer is equipped to save it | Zoe Williams

"All of these questions are ultimately asking the same thing: should Starmer try to save his skin by feinting left or right? As for Labour, why does it look so aimless, how can it convey its mission rather than merely a list of policies, how can it stop backtracking and how did it achieve this deep, cross-spectrum unpopularity?"

"Whenever Reform is riding high, the victory camp get more splenetic: are you seriously saying you won't just knuckle down, support this party, do whatever it takes to defeat the hard right? It's like being told off by your mum in a supermarket. Have your tantrum, but not here, not now."

"Labour should worry far more about leftwing defectors than rightwing ones, because (top lines) there are more of"

Labour under Keir Starmer confronts persistent internal debate about balancing ideological inclusivity with electoral pragmatism. The party struggles with questions about whether to accommodate its left flank, manage threats from both Reform and the Greens, and articulate a coherent mission beyond policy lists. Leadership decisions by figures like Morgan McSweeney and Shabana Mahmood raise questions about strategic direction. The core dilemma remains whether Labour should prioritize values alignment or electoral victory. Research from Persuasion UK suggests Labour faces greater electoral risk from left-wing voter defection than from right-wing competition, challenging the conventional wisdom that prioritizes defeating Reform above all other considerations.

Read at www.theguardian.com