Here's the lesson of the Andy Burnham saga: Labour needs a new leader fast | Polly Toynbee

"Declaring war on Andy Burnham anoints him as a northern martyr and hero, and casts Keir Starmer as a coward. Many opposed Burnham throwing down the gauntlet for all the problems it would have caused if he won. If he had run, and won, Starmer would have a choice: squeeze him python-tight within the fold, or confront any leadership manoeuvring head on."

"What timing for this decision! Starmer, along with his chancellor, business secretary and other chief allies are due to depart for China on Tuesday: his absence from PMQs, from the weekly parliamentary Labour party meeting and from TV studios is a blunder. Why this provocation when obstacles aplenty were already in Burnham's way, with no easy route to No 10? Even those who are not particularly his supporters see how boldly he was ready to hazard his political career on an uncertain byelection at a time of wild political volatility."

"He could have lost to Reform or to the Greens, or been hindered by a pro-Gaza independent, and that would have finished him politically. But he had a good chance of winning: now, if that seat gifts Nigel Farage his ninth MP, excoriating blame will fall on Starmer. The byelection to replace Burnham as Manchester mayor would indeed have been mortally dangerous: a Reform win would have been a disaster, not just for Labour but for the future of the country. Anger at that needless loss might well have terminated any Burnham leadership bid."

Labour's leadership used procedural tactics to block Andy Burnham from contesting the Gorton and Denton byelection, elevating him into a northern martyr while casting Keir Starmer as timid. The decision coincides with Starmer's planned trip to China, removing him from PMQs, the weekly parliamentary Labour party meeting and media appearances. Burnham risked losing to Reform, the Greens or a pro-Gaza independent but also had a credible chance to win, which could have challenged Starmer's authority. Blocking his candidacy may transfer blame to Starmer if the seat boosts Nigel Farage, and deepens divisions within Labour over market-sensitive remarks.

Read at www.theguardian.com