Alejandro Kirk has been out since April 3 with a fractured left thumb. Recent updates indicate he is catching bullpens and live batting practice, and he could begin rehab assignments soon, though he is behind with hitting. Kirk’s return would strengthen the Blue Jays, as he produced strong 2025 value metrics, including high fWAR and Fielding Run Value among catchers. His absence has led Tyler Heineman and rookie Brandon Valenzuela to share catching duties. Valenzuela has produced more offense, including more RBIs, hits, and home runs, while Heineman has struggled and had a first home run after a long hit drought. Valenzuela also draws more walks and sees more pitches, while strikeout rates differ modestly. Defensive differences remain smaller but still favor Valenzuela.
"Kirk has been missing from the Blue Jays' lineup since April 3, when he fractured his left thumb off a foul tip against the Chicago White Sox. According to the most recent injury updates from the Blue Jays, Kirk has been catching bullpens and live BPs. He's further behind with the bat, but could start rehab assignments soon."
"There's no doubt that getting Kirk back will be a huge boost for the Blue Jays. In 2025, he had the second-highest fWAR on the team (4.7), slotting behind George Springer (5.2). Among all catchers in 2025, Kirk had the second-highest fWAR and the second-highest Fielding Run Value (FRV) (22)."
"In his absence, Tyler Heineman has shared catching duties with rookie Brandon Valenzuela. At first, Valenzuela was meant to be a temporary addition to the Blue Jays' lineup until Kirk returned. However, his performance, coupled with Heineman's struggles, may have muddied the waters about who to keep when Kirk is healthy."
"Offensively, Valenzuela has the upper hand. He's slashing .239/.330/.398 compared to Heineman's .152/.188/.197. He has 10 RBIs to Heineman's 4 and 19 hits, while Heineman has only 10. Valenzuela has also hit four home runs. Meanwhile, Heineman hit his first home run of the season in Saturday's 5-2 win over the Pittsburgh Pirates. That was Heineman's first hit since May 1 against the Minnesota Twins."
Read at BlueJaysNation
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]