"There is a good argument for both players. They both are great players and can help push the franchise forward. But wouldn't it be better to have your homegrown talent do that? Bichette was a draft pick of the organization in 2016 and has quickly risen to being one of the best hitters on the planet. Bichette may not hit as many home runs as much as Tucker, but he will have 180 plus hits in a season."
"Additionally, he'll have a higher batting average by at least 10 points, if not more. Bichette has also shown he can come up clutch in big moments like he did with his home run in Game 7 of the 2025 World Series. Additionally, the Blue Jays don't need another outfielder who slots in as DH from time to time. They have that in Santander and Springer."
The Toronto Blue Jays face a likely choice between re-signing homegrown shortstop Bo Bichette and pursuing outfielder Kyle Tucker due to budgetary constraints under Rogers ownership. Bo Bichette, a 2016 draft pick, offers elite contact hitting, consistent 180-plus hit seasons, a higher batting average, and proven clutch performance, including a Game 7 World Series home run in 2025. Kyle Tucker provides superior power and outfield/DH versatility, but the roster already includes options like Santander and Springer who can fill DH/outfield roles. Given roster composition and financial limits, retaining Bichette delivers continuity and dependable offensive production over adding Tucker's additional power.
Read at Jays Journal
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]