John Tavares signed with Toronto in 2018 on a seven-year, $77 million contract that carried an $11 million AAV and raised expectations. The contract was among the NHL's highest salaries and stayed top-ten until it expired after the 2024-2025 season. Despite consistent secondary scoring, leadership, and international success, criticism focused on the contract's size amid the Maple Leafs' repeated playoff shortcomings and a cap structure that delayed peers surpassing his pay. A new team-friendly extension and a younger core reduce financial scrutiny, allowing recognition of Tavares's on-ice contributions and professional qualities.
Along with it came the weight of a massive free-agent contract and sky-high expectations for the homegrown Toronto product. Signed in 2018 to a seven-year, $77 million deal that stunned the hockey world, Tavares arrived in Toronto as a key piece that would help lead the Leafs to a title. However, the team's year-over-year playoff struggles brought skepticism to the franchise's strategy of allocating most of its salary cap space to only a few star players.
The $11 million price tag of Tavares became a focal point for criticism; his leadership, consistency, and professionalism were often overlooked. But now, with a new team-friendly extension and the Maple Leafs' spotlight shifting to a younger core, Tavares finds himself in a new position: playing free of financial scrutiny, and finally deserving of long-overdue appreciation. What Tavares added to the Leafs was often dismissed due to his large contract. Released from the burden of that deal, it's time to recognize the value he brings.
Collection
[
|
...
]