"First it was rumored with all parties obliquely denying it, and then it happened: the Giants have hired Tony Vitello from the University of Tennessee to be their next manager. This sort of thing has never happened before - a college coach with no MLB-affiliated coaching experience moving straight to a managerial position, or so the various "news" outlets keep indicating. The question today is simple: how well do you think this is going to work out for Vitello and the Giants?"
"There's no Rafael Devers at Tennessee or elsewhere; even if a college kid has a Devers-esque personality and propensity for tepid drama, they don't have his leverage. More to the point, there may just be a set of unknown unknowns that come from this sort of transition that could derail whatever Giants head honcho Buster Posey and Vitello would try to achieve from this move."
"On the flip side, the landscape of MLB managing is so staid bordering on miserable that taking a chance on a guy who's had a ton of success in an adjacent context isn't necessarily a poorly-crafted, low-upside gamble. (Don't believe me? The spiciest thing an MLB manager said this year is maybe Dave Roberts' quip about ruining baseball.) Maybe it goes great and sets up a smattering of copycats,"
Tony Vitello has been hired as the San Francisco Giants' next manager despite lacking MLB-affiliated coaching experience. The hire represents an unprecedented jump from college coaching directly to an MLB managerial role. Potential downsides include managing a mixed clubhouse of young, lower-leverage players alongside multimillionaire veterans, plus unpredictable 'unknown unknowns' from the transition. Potential upsides include injecting energy, candor, and fresh approaches into an often-staid managerial landscape, and the possibility that strategy and tactics can be supplied by specialists while the manager focuses on interpersonal leadership. The move could succeed and inspire similar hires, or falter if clubhouse dynamics or unforeseen challenges overwhelm adaptation.
Read at Battery Power
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]