8 Magic Spoon Protein Cereals, Ranked - Tasting Table

Magic Spoon protein cereal uses casein and whey protein and provides 12 to 14 grams of protein per serving with 0 to 3 grams of sugar. Eight varieties were tasted, including options like soda, coffee, granola, and chips previously tried for protein content. The tasting focused on flavor quality both dry and with milk, emphasizing whether the cereal’s taste and texture held up without milk’s creaminess. Rankings were based on overall flavor, how well each flavor matched its description, and whether any varieties were not worth eating. Honey Nut was described as sweet and slightly nutty with a familiar, nostalgic chew, using a crunchy yet somewhat soft texture, while still delivering a protein-forward, healthier feel.

"Magic Spoon's protein cereal selection is based on casein and whey protein. The cereals I tried have between 12 and 14 grams of protein and 0 to 3 grams of sugar per serving. I tried eight, but the company has other offerings and even limited or seasonal options, if you're interested in eating other flavors."

"I tend to snack on a lot of nice cereals dry, so having a tasty cereal without the creaminess of milk to distract from it is an important factor for me. However, I tried them with milk as well. Ultimately, my ranking is based on the overall flavor of the cereal: which ones were the most flavorful and interesting (with or without milk), which ones offered what the flavor said it would, and which ones should be skipped altogether."

"I find the Honey Nut marginally more enticing than the Classic Marshmallow, because it delivers that sweet and slightly nutty note that you get from other honey nut-inspired cereals. It has a nostalgic and familiar element as you chew, but it comes in a new application with Magic Spoon's signature crunchy, yet somewhat soft, texture. I like honey nut cereals, but this one isn't quite as indulgent and satisfying."

"Luckily, though, we have reached the part of the list where, if I had this in my pantry, I would happily take it out to have as a protein-rich snack. It fared pretty well in a previous ranking of high protein cereals,"

Read at Tasting Table