Study: alley-loaded development can save money vs. front-loaded homes

"Alleys became a signature element of urban development as industrialism took hold, a time before the missing middle of housing affordability went missing. Major U.S. cities grew up with alleys behind homes to keep deliveries and sanitation out of sight of the main street. The garage, however, became the hallmark of sprawling suburban development fed by a rising car culture as residents left urban areas. Buyers appreciate the convenience and visible security of pulling directly into their garagesperks that also enhance curb appeal"

"The Center for New Urbanism, which favors alleys, challenged the prevailing preference for garages in a new study by Michael Mehaffy, president of Structura Naturalis Inc., and Laurence Qamar, principal at the town planning firm Qamar & Associates. This analysis is focused on the cost issue alone and is separate from the consideration of the other documented benefits from alley-loaded homes,"

"Mehaffy and Qamar show evidence that driveway costs often offset alley paving costs, especially with standard lot sizes. Wider streets for front-loaded, garage-front homes raise infrastructure costs. Alley-loaded homes use narrower lots, providing additional affordable housing options. Their study compares alley-loaded and front-loaded residences using infrastructure costs per lot. Researchers analyze, compare, and contrast pavement, utility costs, and land yield for both development types. Alley-loaded developments often cost less per lot than front-loaded ones, researchers find."

Alleys historically served industrializing cities by keeping deliveries and sanitation behind homes, while garages became central to sprawling suburban development driven by car culture. Garages offer homeowners convenient, visible security and enhance curb appeal, and front-loaded designs can avoid alley infrastructure and maintenance. Cost-focused analysis finds driveway expenses often offset alley paving costs, and wider streets required by front-loaded layouts raise infrastructure spending. Alley-loaded developments use narrower lots, increase land yield, and typically lower pavement and utility costs per lot. Overall, alley-loaded designs often cost less per lot and support more affordable, walkable neighborhood forms.

Read at www.housingwire.com