Are mortgage buydowns a lifeline or a risk for new homebuyers?

"The debate over the large builders' elevated use of mortgage buydowns and the potential risks to buyers isn't new. Reigniting the argument, a recent report from the American Enterprise Institute (AEI) asserts that mortgage buydowns among the large builders are artificially inflating new home prices, therefore creating a risk for buyers in the resale market. Publications and industry analysts, citing AEI's data, added that the practice may help big builders at the expense of their homebuyer customers."

"Large homebuilding firms would counter that mortgage buydowns remain the most effective financial tool to close the growing affordability gap, providing households with a bridge from rising rents to homeownership. Buydowns, they assert, allow borrowers to build equity faster, effectively a better deal for homebuyers than pure price cuts. The debate that has sprung up centers on whether the widespread use of mortgage buydowns has been a net benefit or a net negative for buyers and the housing market at large."

"By then, public builders had already begun using mortgage buydowns and continued to do so aggressively. That left builders in the lurch, particularly large new residential subdivision builders that had a lot of inventory. And so they started using permanent buydowns, quite naturally, to move that inventory rather than lowering prices, Ed Pinto, Senior Fellow and Codirector at AEI Housing Center, tells HousingWire."

AEI asserts mortgage buydowns among large builders are artificially inflating new-home prices and creating resale risks for buyers. Publications and analysts cited AEI data suggesting the practice benefits big builders at buyers' expense. Large homebuilders argue buydowns bridge affordability gaps by lowering initial payments, helping households transition from rising rents to homeownership and enabling faster equity accumulation versus price cuts. Widespread use of buydowns rose after the 30-year fixed mortgage rate jumped from about 3% in 2022 to over 7% in October 2022, prompting public builders to employ permanent buydowns to move inventory rather than reduce prices. The net effect on buyers and the market remains contested.

Read at www.housingwire.com