The New 'Poor Door': Amenity Fees Are Too High for Affordable Housing Tenants
Briefly

The New 'Poor Door': Amenity Fees Are Too High for Affordable Housing Tenants
"Joseph Jones, 61, is standing in the well-furnished lobby of his apartment building on Bruckner Boulevard. the South Bronx. The clock is ticking. According to a building policy, tenants can only spend 15 minutes at a time hanging out in the building's lobby. Just downstairs in the basement is a lounge, game room, and gym where tenants are welcome to stay as long as they like. It just costs $250 a month."
"Affordable housing in New York City is increasingly found in mixed-income buildings. In exchange for a tax break, subsidy, or more square footage, developers set aside a percentage of units in new buildings for affordable housing available through the city's affordable housing lottery. Tenants who win lottery apartments or use a voucher in new luxury apartment buildings in the five boroughs told City Limits that the high cost of amenity fees creates income-segregated spaces within their buildings."
Low-income tenants who secure units through the city's lottery or rental vouchers often cannot afford optional amenity fees in new mixed-income luxury buildings. Building policies can limit non-paying residents' time in common spaces while paid lounges, gyms, and game rooms remain accessible only to those who pay fees of around $250 monthly. The fee barrier creates tension among affordable tenants, market-rate residents, and management, producing a two-tiered living environment. Developers provide affordable units in exchange for subsidies or zoning benefits. City housing authorities express that tenants should have equal access, yet few rules govern amenity pricing.
Read at City Limits
Unable to calculate read time
[
|
]