Pirates! Is the Very Model of a Modern Major Debacle
Briefly

In 'The Penzance Musical,' the creators aim to inject a sense of fun into Gilbert and Sullivan's classic operetta by reimagining it in late-1800s New Orleans with a jazz twist. While the adaptation is visually engaging and energetic, it often sacrifices the operetta's wit and subtlety for broad humor and spectacle. The title and its exclamation point suggest a lively experience, yet the contrast between the original material and the new interpretations raises questions about the integrity of the adaptation. Moments of genuine brilliance shine through, hinting at the original's charm.
The exclamation mark in 'The Penzance Musical' reveals its attempt to be a lively, comedic adaptation, often sacrificing nuance for broad humor and spectacle.
Director Scott Ellis and adapter Rupert Holmes aim for a familiar, fun musical vibe, transforming classical elements into something that fits a vibrant, jazzy New Orleans setting.
Reset in late-1800s New Orleans, the adaptation blends jazz and Broadway elements, but raises questions about its title and fidelity to the original operetta.
Moments of the original Gilbert and Sullivan brilliance occasionally break through the new material, providing glimpses of the show's true artistic potential.
Read at Vulture
[
|
]