Lily Allen review pop star makes much-anticipated comeback but where is the West End Girl?

"A raw document of marital betrayal and neglect, it was a new kind of divorce album for the post-tabloid celebrity, inspired by Allen's own separation from actor David Harbour. It earned Allen rave reviews and a place alongside Miranda July's All Fours in a contemporary canon of emancipatory, autofictional art for modern (heterosexual) women."

"Split into two acts, West End Girl Live certainly begins with theatrical flair. A string ensemble named the Dallas Minor Trio after one of the album's standout tracks takes to the stage for a version of Allen's 2008 hit The Fear. The crowd enthusiastically sings along to karaoke-style lyrics on a screen behind the trio."

"Staging hits like this might be cute as a 10-minute-long introduction, but as the entire, 45-minute first half of a much-anticipated comeback show it risks testing the patience of the audience; a compromise between committing to a full album show and avoiding accusations of not playing the hits."

Lily Allen's West End Girl album, released in October 2025, documents her separation from actor David Harbour and earned critical acclaim alongside contemporary autofictional art. The album's narrative structure suggested strong potential for theatrical staging. Allen's theatre tour of West End Girl Live opens with the Dallas Minor Trio performing a string arrangement of her 2008 hit The Fear, establishing theatrical flair. However, this concept extends through nine additional songs in the first 45-minute act, becoming repetitive. While some songs like Not Fair work as Bridgerton-style instrumentals, others like Hard Out Here suffer from the arrangement, and projecting its tone-deaf lyrics proves problematic. This extended prelude represents a compromise between committing to a full album show and playing recognizable hits, ultimately risking audience engagement.

Read at www.theguardian.com