Why Creative Agencies Lost-and What They Must Do to Start Winning Again | Muse by Clios

"Media shops organized around a simple machine: More client cash flowing through their pipes means more revenue. Fees. Volume incentives. Data leverage. Margin on margin. Their economics compound. A dollar placed becomes infrastructure for the next dollar. Creative agencies built the opposite. Every idea is a bespoke project. Every campaign starts from scratch. Deliver, invoice, repeat. There's no compounding. No flywheel. Just craft sold by the hour."

"When media and creative split decades ago, creative lost access to the volume economics that kept them powerful. Media kept the machine. Creative kept the romance. But romance doesn't pay for growth. Creativity as a System Media didn't win because they're smarter about brand building. They won because they built self-reinforcing systems: More spend → better data → stronger performance → more spend."

"Here's what's different now. Creativity has finally become infrastructure. Not metaphorically. Literally. AI lets you turn creative into systems. Ideas become logic. Campaigns become templates. Brand becomes code. A design system isn't just a style guide anymore. It's an engine that generates thousands of variations, optimizes itself and plugs directly into commerce, media and product. That's not automation replacing creativity. It's creativity becoming scalable for the first time."

Media agencies built scalable, compounding businesses by turning client spend into recurring revenue through fees, volume incentives, data leverage and layered margins. Creative agencies relied on bespoke projects and one-off deliverables, producing linear economics with no flywheel. The historical split left creative without volume economics while media retained self-reinforcing systems that drove growth. Advances in AI convert creative outputs into systems and code, enabling design systems, templates and adaptive creative that optimize to performance data. Creativity as infrastructure allows brand expression to plug into commerce and media, making creative work scalable and competitive with tech and consulting firms.

Read at Muse by Clios | Discover the latest creative marketing and advertising news. Muse by Clio is the premier news site covering creativity in advertising and beyond.