The Rolling Corruption behind the Letitia James Prosecution - emptywheel

"Any remaining doubt about the existence of DOJ's possession of material that might go towards establishing AG James' vindictive or selective claims was obviated by the Government's November 4, 2025, filing of its Notice of Reasons for Not Providing Pre-Vindictive/Selective Prosecution Motion Related Discovery. See DE-46. The Government's filing states that it "bears no such obligation until a defendant 'overcomes a significant barrier by advancing objective evidence tending to show the existence of prosecutorial misconduct.'" Id. at 1 (quoting Wilson, 262 F.3d at 315).68 AG James has exceeded that burden, and more."

"If the Government did not believe it possessed "vindictive/selective prosecution-related discovery," DE-46 at 4, the Government could have so stated, without filing notice of its intent not to produce such discovery. Yet the November 4 Notice seemingly contradicts what the government has previously suggested, which is that it has in its possession some discovery relevant to the defense's prosecutorial vindictiveness argument that would be produced. Id. at 2. The Government started that process of producing such discovery, and on October 30, produced just seven news articles about the James investigation or case. That is all. Then, in a move suggesting the Government found additional items which it did not want to reveal or produce, the Notice followed on November 4, suggesting more such discovery exists. Public reporting from the day before also indicated that FHFA's acting inspector general, Joe Allen, was fired from his role on November 3 "after he made efforts to provide key information to prosecutors in [Ms. Halligan's] office, according to four sources. The information he turned over was constitutionally"

The Government filed a November 4, 2025 notice refusing to provide pre-vindictive/selective-prosecution discovery, citing no obligation until a defendant advances objective evidence under Wilson. The filing implied the Government possessed such material despite producing only seven news articles on October 30. The Notice followed that production and suggested additional discovery exists that the Government did not want to disclose. Public reporting indicated FHFA acting inspector general Joe Allen was fired on November 3 after efforts to provide key information to prosecutors, according to multiple sources.

Read at emptywheel