Federal Judge Allows Jury to View Key Luigi Mangione Evidence in Major Blow to Defense

"The judge saying that the search of Mangione's backpack at the McDonald's was illegal, and so certain items there are out. But the key evidence in this case, the alleged murder weapon and a handwriting diaries of Mangione are in. How the judge broke this down, he said that the search at the McDonald'sit was not exigent circumstances. There was no public safety risk involved. There was no concern that he could reach into the backpack, since the officers had moved it far away from them."

"And within that search, which is not allowed to come into trial, they found the magazine of the bullets. They also found the his cell phone, his passport, a wallet, and a computer chip. So, none of that evidence can come in. But all the material that was recovered when the backpack was searched back at the station, the judge said that was a legal search. They conducted it pursuant to the Altoona Police Department's procedures handling an inventory search."

"So, that means that the gun, the handwritings where Mangione had written about his frustrations with the healthcare industry that he wanted to target insurance, that he said he was going to look at the bean counters. You know, he's accused of gunning down the UnitedHealthcare CEO just outside of the hotel in Manhattan, where they were holding their annual investor conference. That information, those pieces of evidence can come in."

A federal judge ruled that a gun and notebook allegedly linking Luigi Mangione to the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson can be presented to jurors. The defense argued the items were seized without a required search warrant. The judge found the McDonald's backpack search was illegal because it was not an exigent circumstances situation and involved no public safety risk. The judge said officers had moved the backpack far away, so there was no concern it could be accessed. Items found during that unlawful search, including a bullet magazine and other personal items, were excluded. Evidence recovered later during a lawful inventory search at the station, including the alleged murder weapon and handwritten materials about targeting the healthcare industry, was allowed. Mangione faces federal and state murder charges.

Read at www.mediaite.com