Historian Len Scales challenges traditional views of the Holy Roman Empire as a failed experiment in nation-building, arguing that its decentralized nature played a crucial role in shaping early German identity. Scales asserts that rather than seeing medieval Germany as lacking cohesion, we should recognize how collective identity developed in opposition to others, especially through conflicts such as the Investiture Contest. This conflict reframed perceptions of imperial authority and ultimately fostered a more defined sense of Germanness, illustrating the complexities of national identity formation during the Middle Ages.
The role of the 'Investiture Contest'...is important in a number of seemingly paradoxical ways. The crucial formative interventions in imperial dynamics highlight how conflict shaped identity.
Scales argues that collective identity formed in the Middle Ages did not stem from a failure to unify but was profoundly influenced by the empire's complex relationships.
Collection
[
|
...
]