"Soon after Medicare, Medicaid, and the Hart-Celler Act, also known as the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965, became law, the federal government began to label certain geographic areas as Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs), which designated an inadequate number of physicians in relation to the population. HPSAs were generally populated with people who were low-income, elderly, homeless, incarcerated, and migrant laborers - poor, medically complicated patients with public insurance and a likelihood of premature death."
"In a matter of months, hospitals in shortage areas were able to use the Hart-Celler Act to quickly fill their vacancies, especially in primary care specialties, with resident physicians from India, Pakistan, and the Philippines. While non-white medical care workers have a long history in the United States, much of this labor was feminized and positioned well below the doctor in the medical hierarchy. The influx of predominantly male foreign physicians was different."
"These practitioners had the potential to dilute the authority and prestige of the doctor's social position - a position that was already vulnerable by mid-century. Although foreign physicians' labor was in high demand, organized medicine and the broader public regularly challenged their presence and expertise using ambiguous metrics of competence and protean standards of quality."
"Published social scientific studies characterized foreign physicians as lacking in leadership potential, anxious, unable to learn independently, and possessing poor patient skills. Despite these racialized and gendered critiques, these doctors"
After Medicare, Medicaid, and the Hart-Celler Act of 1965 became law, the federal government designated Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) where physician numbers were inadequate for the population. These areas often served low-income, elderly, homeless, incarcerated, and migrant laborers, who faced complex medical needs and higher risk of premature death. Hospitals used the Hart-Celler Act to fill vacancies quickly, especially in primary care, with resident physicians from India, Pakistan, and the Philippines. Foreign physicians were predominantly male and entered a medical hierarchy where the doctor’s authority and prestige were already vulnerable. Organized medicine and the public challenged foreign physicians’ presence and expertise through ambiguous measures of competence and shifting standards of quality, supported by studies that described them as lacking leadership potential and patient skills.
#immigration-policy #healthcare-workforce-shortages #medicare-and-medicaid #medical-hierarchy-and-professional-authority #racialized-credentialing
Read at Truthout
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]